Ten gym facilities across Madison, Sun Prairie, Middleton, Waunakee, and Fitchburg made our 2026 list. These venues range from full-service sports clubs and personal training studios to specialized CrossFit boxes and boxing and wrestling academies. Ratings for these facilities span from 4.2 to 5.0 stars, reflecting a high standard of service and equipment across the region.
Our rankings are determined by multiplying the star rating by the log of the review count, with no paid placements influencing the order.
1. Princeton Club – East
Located at 1726 Eagan Rd in Madison, this facility holds a 4.5 rating from 993 reviews. Members describe it as a diverse community that welcomes Special Olympians and provides a supportive environment through its staff and classes.
2. Princeton Club – West
This Madison location at 8080 Watts Rd has a 4.2 rating based on 715 reviews. The facility includes a pool, basketball courts, and a traditional strength area, with group workout classes managed via a mobile app.
3. Prairie Athletic Club
Based in Sun Prairie with a 4.5 rating from 415 reviews, this club offers programming for all ages. Services available at this location include group fitness classes and personal training.
4. Harbor Athletic Club
Located at 2529 Allen Blvd in Middleton, this facility maintains a 4.6 rating from 316 reviews.
5. Fortify Fitness Collective
With a perfect 5.0 rating from 176 reviews, this Waunakee gym is noted for its variety of workouts and coaching staff that help members look forward to their classes.
6. Anytime Fitness
This Middleton location at 1011 N Gammon Rd earns a 4.8 rating from 214 reviews. Visitors describe the space as clean and up to date.
7. CrossFit Mojo
Located in Fitchburg, this gym holds a 5.0 rating from 145 reviews. It is cited as a good option for those looking to build skills under the guidance of coach Tmac.
8. Allegro Fitness: CrossFit + Hyrox (formerly CrossFit Big Dane)
This Madison facility has a 4.9 rating from 130 reviews. Reviewers highlight the welcoming community, flexible programming for individual needs, and the quality of the coaching.
9. JJ’s Boxing & Wrestling LLC
Specializing in boxing and wrestling in Sun Prairie, this gym has a 4.9 rating from 114 reviews. It is recognized for its dedicated coaches and team dynamic.
10. Alloy Personal Training – Middleton, WI
Located at 8333 Greenway Blvd in Middleton, this studio holds a 4.9 rating from 113 reviews. The facility is noted for making workout adjustments to accommodate various ailments.
How we ranked these
Our list is generated using a formula that balances average user ratings with the total volume of feedback. For more details, see our methodology.