Commonwealth Running Company in Evanston, Illinois

“This company is fantastic! The shipping is super fast. I donu2019t usually keep the box of my shoes, but itu2019s in amazing condition. Iu2019m just so glad that they show up on my shop pay app. Their prices are really competitive. Iu2019ll definitely be a repeat customer!”

— Ferdinand P. · ★★★★★ · 2025-5-1

“I have been searching for weeks for a pair of shoes that can actually accommodate my feet. I have severe ingrown toenails and very wide feet, so I need an extremely wide toe box. Iu2019ve gone to department stores, major brand name stores u2014 everywhere u2014 and couldnu2019t find anything that worked. The minute I called this store, Jacob was incredibly accommodating and helpful. He knew shoes and sizing off the top of his head. ”

— Christina G. · ★★★★★

“Experience so far with Commonwealth has been outstanding! Iu2019m glad I found these guys while searching for some new treads for the upcoming season. Became a loyalty member from the first purchase and Iu2019d suggest the program to anyone who is planning on purchasing from them. Customer service has been beyond great! Emails or phone call they have been a pleasure to work with. Quick replies and quick to resolve anything t”

— Bob C. · ★★★★★

“They are the best! Best return policy (wanting you to feel happy and comfortable with your purchase). At ease in spending the time to make sure you are buying what you need. The person who waited on me was an incredibly good listener to my response to wearing one shoe or another and finding exactly was felt right! Can't say enough good things about the store and the people working there.”

— Jacques R. · ★★★★★

“Donu2019t trust this company! Scam likely! I placed an order for the Nike AlphaFly Laser Orange shoes on Jan. 30th, after clicking on an ad for the exact same shoe on Commonwealthu2019s Instagram ad. 2 weeks later (Feb. 13) I notice there is still no shipping information. I contact them and they said u201cit was an error because we accidentally shipped the shoes to someone else but we have them now and we are shipping them out t”

— Dr. F. · ★☆☆☆☆

“The whole point of shopping online is that we are buying something without wearing it. Not allowing customers to return items bought online is a moronic policy, whether they were discounted or not. Borderline scam if you can list your price any amount you want and then bring it down 20% to claim clearance or discount, and say it's policy not to accept returns on discounted items. Will be filing complaints with busine”

— Nirmal E. · ★☆☆☆☆

“Commonwealth always ships unbelievable fast. Very impressed. I live on East coast, so I can't visit store. I get size 11.5 95% of time. Always fit Last one this week 11.5 but way too big. SAD I don't think I can return? A waste of $125. Sneakers are ON my favorite”

— Bill T. · ★★★☆☆

“The young staff was engaged and wonderful. Really listened to what I needed the shoes for, my foot build etc. I ended up getting 2 pair of shoes, they brought me 10 different pair to try on. Great job!”

— Carrie F. · ★★★★★