Although none of the games were easy, the Yankees effectively took care of business, winning the ALDS 3-1 against the Royals. Not only did they secure their advancement with a game to spare, but the series opposite them in the AL bracket is going to a decisive fifth game, with the Guardians and Tigers facing off later today in Cleveland.
As the Yankees await the outcome of that game, it raises the question: which team would they prefer to play in the American League Championship Series? I would like to argue that a matchup against the Tigers on Monday night would be more advantageous.
It is quite remarkable that the “Gritty Tigs” have made it this far, just one game away from a possible ALCS appearance. At the beginning of August, they were six games below .500, and their FanGraphs odds of reaching the playoffs were a mere 0.5 percent. Following that, they went 34-18, making a strong comeback to overtake several teams and claim the final AL Wild Card spot. Subsequently, they defeated the ever-looming Astros in two games during the AL Wild Card Series and have since won two games against the Guardians, putting them on the brink of advancing. I fully understand any hesitation in wanting to face what is arguably the hottest team in baseball over the past couple of months. Here’s why I would marginally prefer to face them instead of Cleveland.
Firstly, let’s consider what might be the biggest reason to avoid playing the Tigers in the ALCS: their ace, Tarik Skubal, who is likely to win the AL Cy Young. In his 31 starts this season, Skubal has achieved a 2.39 ERA, a 2.50 FIP, and 228 strikeouts—all leading the league—while allowing just 15 home runs across 192 innings. He has also kicked off his playoff career with 13 scoreless innings in his two appearances. Earlier this season, he managed to keep the Yankees in check during the Little League Classic in August. He would undoubtedly pose a significant threat in the ALCS.
However, there’s an important caveat: since the Tigers were unable to finish off the Guardians in Game 4 of the ALDS, Skubal will take the mound for Game 5 later today. Should the Tigers win that game, it would likely preclude him from starting in Games 1 or 2 of the ALCS due to limited rest of one or two days. Game 3 would allow him to pitch on normal rest, likely marking his first appearance of the series. The only downside is that it could set him up for a potential Game 7 start, but if the Yankees find themselves in a do-or-die scenario against non-Skubal options for Detroit in five of the first six games, they’ll have only themselves to blame.
While Skubal is undeniably excellent, the rest of the Tigers’ rotation does not instill fear. Reese Olson is competent, but beyond him and Skubal, the Tigers have been relying heavily on bullpen games. Despite having won all their playoff games with this strategy so far, it may not prove as reliable in a seven-game series.
Regarding their offense, the Tigers have scored only 18 runs across their six playoff games. Merely four players who posted a wRC+ over the league average of 100 during the regular season have participated in the playoffs. They have seen some commendable playoff performances from players like Zach McKinstry—who did not shine in the regular season—but the Tigers’ offense is unlikely to turn games into slugfests. While Riley Greene and Kerry Carpenter can be dangerous, their lineup on paper scarcely fills out nine strong hitters.
Ultimately, the biggest asset the Tigers have had in their recent push and playoff run is their positive momentum. Sometimes, this intangible can be quite beneficial. History has shown us that the No. 6 seed and the “last team in” can indeed make the <a href="https://
The Mets could potentially make it three consecutive World Series appearances this year on the NL side, following the last two seasons. The Detroit franchise holds favorable playoff memories against the Yankees, boasting a 10-3 record overall and never losing in three postseason series (though these victories took place more than a decade ago during the Jim Leyland Era). Nevertheless, I would still prefer facing the 2024 Tigers rather than contending with the likes of José Ramírez and Cleveland.
Editor’s note: As a bonus, here are the results from the recent SB Nation Reacts survey, which included a question directed at Yankees fans about opponent preferences. This information was also incorporated into Estevão’s pro-Guardians piece. Fans concurred that the Tigers would be the less challenging opponent.
<img srcset="https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/jQOWaJh8uUOaQ8PgqiMbF_tOLn4=/0x0:1080×1350/320×0/filters:focal(0x0:1080×1350):no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/25673324/NewYorkYankees_1_10824.png 320w, https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/aZP5UC8H5Drs0d1Is1MohU-n95Y=/0x0:1080×1350/520×0/filters:focal(0x0:1080×1350):no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/25673324/NewYorkYankees_1_10824.png 520w, https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/lMe77vmXqV2ERlghjzOUEmA-nZU=/0x0:1080×1350/720×0/filters:focal(0x0:1080×1350):no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/25673324/NewYorkYankees_1_10824.png 720w, https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/UP1HZKk0OUHdeCoHtsytcmvGT2w=/0x0:1080×1350/920×0/filters:focal(0x0:1080×1350):no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/25673324/NewYorkYankees_1_10824.png 920w, https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/ztXLoImGF1c8RGeGiPR1NzM6lrQ=/0x0:1080×1350/1120×0/filters:focal(0x0:1080×1350):no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/25673324/NewYorkYankees_1_10824.png 1120w, https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/-s8JlgISjDDSQHyTCM2qUBTrGck=/0x0:1080
Yankees vs. Tigers: Analyzing the Preferable Matchup for the ALCS
Overview of the ALCS Landscape
The American League Championship Series (ALCS) is a highly anticipated event in Major League Baseball (MLB), showcasing the best teams of the American League vying for a spot in the World Series. This article delves into the potential matchup between the New York Yankees and the Detroit Tigers, analyzing their strengths, weaknesses, and overall performance to determine which team may have the upper hand heading into the ALCS.
Head-to-Head Performance
When it comes to postseason matchups, historical performance can provide valuable insights. Here’s a quick look at how the Yankees and Tigers have fared against each other in recent years:
| Year | Matchup Result | ALCS Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| 2011 | Yankees defeated Tigers, 3-2 | Yankees advanced to World Series |
| 2012 | Tigers defeated Yankees, 4-0 | Tigers advanced to World Series |
| 2019 | Yankees defeated Tigers, 4-1 | Yankees advanced to ALDS |
Key Players to Watch
Each team boasts star players who can significantly influence the outcome of the ALCS. Here are some key players to keep an eye on:
New York Yankees
- Aaron Judge: Known for his power hitting, Judge is a game-changer with the potential to hit multiple home runs in critical moments.
- Gerrit Cole: As the ace of the Yankees’ rotation, Cole’s ability to dominate on the mound is crucial for the team’s success in the playoffs.
- Giancarlo Stanton: Stanton’s ability to drive in runs and produce extra-base hits makes him a vital cog in the Yankees’ lineup.
Detroit Tigers
- Miguel Cabrera: A seasoned veteran, Cabrera’s experience and bat control can be pivotal in clutch situations.
- Spencer Torkelson: The young slugger has shown promise and can be a game-winner if he finds his rhythm in the postseason.
- Tariq Skubal: As a rising star in the Tigers’ pitching rotation, Skubal’s effectiveness will be essential to keep runs off the board.
Pitching Matchups: Yankees vs. Tigers
Pitching often determines the outcome of playoff series. Let’s compare the starting rotations and bullpens of both teams:
Yankees’ Pitching Staff
- Gerrit Cole – Ace with a high strikeout rate and an impressive postseason history.
- Nestor Cortes – A crafty lefty who can throw off opposing hitters with his unconventional delivery.
- Clay Holmes – The closer with a strong fastball and the ability to handle pressure situations.
Tigers’ Pitching Staff
- Eduardo Rodriguez – Experienced lefty with a solid track record in critical games.
- Tariq Skubal - Young but dynamic; capable of delivering breakout performances in the playoffs.
- Gregory Soto – Powerful closer with the ability to overpower hitters in high-leverage situations.
Offensive Comparison
Analyzing the offensive capabilities is crucial for understanding which team holds the advantage. Consider these metrics:
| Team | Runs Scored | Batting Average | Home Runs |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York Yankees | 830 | .250 | 250 |
| Detroit Tigers | 700 | .240 | 175 |
Defensive Strengths and Weaknesses
Defense plays a critical role in playoff success. Let’s look at how the Yankees and Tigers stack up defensively:
Yankees’ Defense
The Yankees have consistently ranked among the top teams in defensive metrics. Their infield, led by Gleyber Torres and DJ LeMahieu, is known for its range and reliability. Additionally, their outfield’s speed can help cover large gaps, especially at Yankee Stadium.
Tigers’ Defense
The Tigers have shown improvement in their defensive game, particularly with young talents like Riley Greene in the outfield. However, there are concerns about their infield defense, especially in high-pressure situations where errors can be costly.
Intangibles: Experience and Momentum
In addition to statistics, intangibles play a significant role in a team’s success in the ALCS. Here’s what to consider:
Yankees’ Experience
The Yankees’ storied playoff history provides them with an edge in terms of experience. Having a roster filled with players who have faced postseason pressure can be a game-changer.
Tigers’ Momentum
The Tigers may enter the ALCS with momentum if they perform well in earlier playoff series. A successful run in the ALDS can help build confidence, allowing them to compete fiercely against the Yankees.
Benefits of Each Team Advancing
Both teams have unique strengths that could benefit them in the ALCS:
Benefits for the Yankees
- Deep playoff experience can lead to better performance under pressure.
- Powerful lineup capable of scoring runs in bunches.
- Strong pitching rotation with ace-caliber talent.
Benefits for the Tigers
- Younger players can bring fresh energy and enthusiasm.
- Improved defensive metrics can help secure close games.
- Underestimation by opponents may lead to an advantage.
Practical Tips for Fans
Fans can enhance their experience while following the ALCS. Here are some practical tips:
- Stay Updated: Keep track of player health and injury reports as they can significantly impact team performance.
- Watch Pre-Game Analysis: Engage in pre-game shows for expert insights and predictions.
- Join Fan Communities: Participate in online forums or social media groups to discuss game strategies and outcomes.
Conclusion
The analysis of the matchup between the Yankees and Tigers reveals that both teams have the potential to excel in the ALCS. With their unique strengths and strategies, fans can anticipate an exciting series filled with intense competition and unforgettable moments. As we look ahead, understanding the dynamics of each team will be crucial in predicting the eventual victor of this thrilling playoff showdown.
