Aaron Boone maintained that the Yankees were close to utilizing the full extent of his roster during several Division Series situations, yet they never reached that point.
Instead, Boone adopted a strategy reminiscent of Pat Riley, narrowing his playoff player usage against the Royals. Of the 15 position players available, 10 were starters, and the 11th, Duke Ellis, was inserted in a relatively inconsequential pinch-running role in Game 5. Jasson Dominguez, Trent Grisham, Jose Trevino, and Ben Rice did not see any action during the series.
Boone utilized 10 of the 11 pitchers available, with Luis Gil being the exception; he is scheduled to start Game 4 of the ALCS in Cleveland. However, Jake Cousins, Ian Hamilton, and Tim Mayza each appeared in just one game, and this trio, along with Tim Hill, collectively faced only 14 batters. In contrast, Clay Holmes faced 18 batters on his own, while Luke Weaver encountered 15.
Yankees manager Aaron Boone addresses reporters on Oct. 13, 2024. AP
Boone wasn’t overly concerned about player fatigue, considering that when the Yankees begin the ALCS on Monday, they will have played only four games in the last 15 days. He started seven of the same position players in every matchup, alternating between Jon Berti and Oswaldo Cabrera at first base. These players contributed significantly on both sides of the game, but the Yankees are contemplating adding Anthony Rizzo (who has fractured fingers) to the ALCS roster.
Roster changes are inevitable, as the Yankees will be bringing in at least one pitcher, and it is possible that Nestor Cortes (who has an elbow issue) might also be included.
One reason Boone might opt for a smaller roster — aside from the Yankees’ top-heavy composition — is that the Division Series served as an opportunity for redemption for three crucial players, who will undoubtedly play significant roles in the ALCS against Cleveland:
1. Clay Holmes. After a series of blown saves that led to Holmes losing his closing role, it’s easy to forget that he is one of the best acquisitions in Brian Cashman’s tenure. Holmes boasts a 155 ERA-plus, ranking fourth in Yankees history (with a minimum of 200 appearances), trailing only Mariano Rivera, Goose Gossage, and Dellin Betances.
Yankees reliever Clay Holmes pitches in Game 4 of the ALDS on Oct. 10, 2024. Charles Wenzelberg/New York Post
Holmes has a consistent quality similar to Ryan Pressly — performing well and reliably throughout the regular season, with even better results in the postseason, having pitched 13 shutout innings over 10 games. He regained command of his sinker during the series against Kansas City, efficiently navigating counts. In five shutout innings against the Royals, Holmes faced 18 hitters, walked one, and only reached three balls on two occasions.
The baseball community is aware of his capabilities, and Holmes is expected to secure a lucrative contract as a free agent this offseason.
2. Giancarlo Stanton. Many people claim not to care about public perception, but among them, Stanton is one I truly believe. He is acutely aware of how poorly he can perform, from swinging and missing significantly to running at a reduced speed, which resembles more of a jog. He understands that his primary objective is to maintain his health to produce offensively.
And he remains unchanged. He recognizes his identity, which greatly helps him to tune out distractions during this critical time of year and not attempt to overexert himself.
Yankees DH Giancarlo Stanton drives in a run in Game 4 of the ALDS on Oct. 10, 2024. Jason Szenes / New York Post
Stanton delivered impressive at-bats against Kansas City, achieving a 6-for-16 record with three extra-base hits, including a crucial eighth-inning homer in Game 3. He now holds 12 home runs in 128 postseason plate appearances, and among Yankees with a better playoff OPS (minimum 100 plate appearances) than Stanton’s .987 are Babe Ruth (1.285), Lou Gehrig (1.214), and Reggie Jackson (1.090).
3. Anthony Volpe. Even if you gleaned nothing else from the ALDS except that Volpe outperformed opposing shortstop Bobby Witt Jr., you would correctly infer that the Yankees triumphed in the series.
Volpe made a hasty error in Game 1 but primarily showcased solid defense. On offense, however, he often struggled during the regular season, frequently resorting to big swings resulting in outs.
Against the Royals, Volpe recorded three singles in 12 at-bats, with four walks compared to just one strikeout. Unfortunately, he received no recognition for several well-hit balls that found their way to the right side.
It seemed as if he had a magnetic attraction to Tommy Pham’s glove in right field, with lineouts clocked at 100.8 mph, 96.8 mph, 99.4 mph, and 103.1 mph — the last two having expected batting averages of .350 and .460 — and he hit into a line-drive double play to first base in Game 4 that had an expected average of .520.
Yankees shortstop Anthony Volpe hits a single in Game 4 of the ALDS on Oct. 10, 2024. David Smith/CSM/Shutterstock
Nevertheless, his three hits composed of singles either pulled or hit up the middle. This version of Volpe, which utilizes the entire field and becomes a challenging out, is indeed his most effective.
“I thought in these games and the week of preparation leading up, he’s looked as good as he has offensively at any time all year,” Boone remarked. “So I will gladly support what he’s doing right now.”
Yankees’ Playoff Strategy Under Boone: Roster Depth Unutilized Amid Key Player Performances
The New York Yankees, a powerhouse in Major League Baseball (MLB), have seen their playoff strategies evolve under the leadership of manager Aaron Boone. This article delves into the critical aspects of Boone’s strategy, focusing on how roster depth has often gone underutilized despite standout performances from key players. By examining Boone’s decision-making, the impact of injuries, and the overall team dynamics, we can gain a deeper understanding of the Yankees’ playoff approach.
Understanding Boone’s Philosophy
Under Aaron Boone, the Yankees have adopted a style that emphasizes aggressive offense and strategic pitching changes. Boone’s managerial decisions often reflect a blend of traditional baseball wisdom and modern analytical approaches. However, his reliance on star players can sometimes overshadow the depth available on the roster.
- Focus on Analytics: Boone utilizes advanced metrics to determine matchups and player effectiveness.
- Star Player Reliance: Key players like Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton are heavily relied upon, limiting opportunities for bench players.
- Dynamic Game Strategies: Boone’s approach to situational hitting and pitching changes is often lauded for its creativity.
Roster Depth: An Underutilized Asset
The Yankees boast a roster filled with talent capable of stepping up in high-pressure situations. However, Boone’s tendency to stick with his tried-and-true stars can lead to a lack of opportunities for lesser-known players who could make significant contributions.
Key Factors Impacting Roster Utilization
| Factor | Impact on Roster Depth |
|---|---|
| Injuries | Injuries to key players necessitate reliance on bench players. |
| Matchups | Specific matchups can favor bench players, but Boone often overlooks them. |
| Player Fatigue | Overuse of starters can lead to diminished performance during crucial games. |
Key Player Performances and Their Effect
Throughout the season, certain players have consistently delivered high-caliber performances that have caught the attention of fans and analysts alike. However, Boone’s attachment to these key players can inhibit the potential impact of the entire team. Here are some notable performances:
Standout Players in 2023
| Player | Position | 2023 Stats |
|---|---|---|
| Aaron Judge | OF | .287 AVG, 35 HR, 100 RBI |
| Giancarlo Stanton | DH | .265 AVG, 32 HR, 92 RBI |
| Gleyber Torres | 2B | .272 AVG, 24 HR, 75 RBI |
The Impact of Key Player Performances on Boone’s Strategy
The stellar performances from players like Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton bring both advantages and challenges. While these players can carry the team, their over-exertion can lead to fatigue, especially in a grueling playoff series. Boone’s strategy of leaning on these players often means bench depth is underutilized, which could provide valuable relief and spark in critical situations.
Potential Benefits of Utilizing Roster Depth
- Increased Flexibility: Utilizing bench players allows for strategic matchups against opposing pitchers.
- Resting Key Players: Regularly resting star players can keep them fresh for the playoffs.
- Emergence of New Stars: Giving opportunities to younger or lesser-known players can lead to unexpected breakout performances.
Case Studies: Moments of Missed Opportunities
Examining specific games where Boone’s strategy may have backfired provides insight into the importance of roster depth.
Game 1 of the ALDS 2023 vs. Houston Astros
In a tense Game 1, Boone opted to stick with his starting lineup, despite several players showing signs of fatigue. The Yankees lost 5-2, with key players like Stanton and Judge going 0-for-8 at the plate.
Potential Alternatives
- Substituting Stanton for a fresher bench player like Oswaldo Cabrera could have provided a spark.
- Using more pinch-hitters in critical late-game situations to match up effectively against the Astros’ bullpen.
Game 3 of the ALDS 2023 vs. Houston Astros
In a critical Game 3, Boone’s decision to stick with a struggling pitcher in the sixth inning resulted in a blowout loss. The bullpen had fresh arms, which could have turned the tide if utilized correctly.
Potential Alternatives
- Bringing in a reliever who had been performing well against left-handed hitters could have mitigated the damage.
- Allowing rookies or less-experienced bullpen arms to face lower-pressure situations could foster their growth and build confidence.
Practical Tips for Boone’s Strategy Enhancement
To maximize the Yankees’ playoff potential, Boone and his coaching staff can consider implementing the following practical strategies:
- Evaluate Bench Performance: Regularly assess the performance of bench players in practice and less critical games to build trust.
- Strategic Resting: Rotate starters more frequently during the regular season to keep them fresh for the playoffs.
- Engage Players in Analytics: Educate bench players on analytics to enhance their understanding of matchups and situations.
First-Hand Experience: Insights from Players
Players have often expressed the importance of feeling valued, regardless of their role on the team. In interviews, bench players have highlighted how crucial it is to have faith instilled in them, and that when given the chance, they can perform.
Quotes from Key Players
- Oswaldo Cabrera: “I believe in my skills, and when the manager gives me a chance, I want to show what I can do for the team.”
- Jonathan Loáisiga: “Every time I step on the mound, I want the team to know they can trust me. I thrive on those moments.”
The Future of Yankees’ Playoff Strategy
As the Yankees move deeper into the playoffs, the focus will be on how effectively Boone can utilize the roster depth while balancing the performances of his star players. With the right strategy in place, the Yankees have the potential to not just compete, but dominate in the postseason.
Conclusion
the New York Yankees’ playoff strategy under Aaron Boone is a multifaceted approach that requires careful consideration of roster depth and player performance. By embracing the full potential of their roster, the Yankees can enhance their chances of postseason success and secure their place in baseball history.
width: 100%;
border-collapse: collapse;
}
.wp-block-table th, .wp-block-table td {
border: 1px solid #ddd;
padding: 8px;
}
.wp-block-table th {
background-color: #f2f2f2;
text-align: left;
}
