Exclusive San Francisco Golf Club Faces community Backlash Over Proposed Maintenance Facility
The San Francisco Golf Club, a prestigious and exclusive private club, is facing scrutiny from the local community over its plans to build a 19,000-square-foot maintenance facility just 40 feet from st.Thomas More school. The project, which has been debated for months, has ignited a controversy highlighting the clash between the interests of wealthy elites and the safety concerns of a nearby school.
The facility, slated for approval by the San Francisco Planning Commission on February 13, 2025, would store fuel for club vehicles and act as a charging station for its fleet of golf carts and lawnmowers equipped with lithium-ion batteries. The potential safety risks posed by storing large quantities of these batteries near a school with 300 students have raised alarm bells among parents and local residents.
Linda Shah, the Parish Council president and a grandmother of a student at St. Thomas More, expressed deep reservations about the proposal. “All they are doing is making changes around the edges,” Shah stated, emphasizing that mere alterations to the plan do not adequately address the fundamental safety concerns. ”Forty feet doesn’t cut it.”
Community concerns have prompted meaningful pushback against the club’s plans. The San Francisco Board of Supervisors last year enacted regulations limiting the storage of lithium-ion batteries in residential buildings, citing the hazards associated with battery fires.The existing environmental review document, however, notably omits any mention of the school’s proximity to the proposed facility.
despite community opposition, the planning commission staff surprisingly recommends approving the conditional-use permit. The club, boasting an impressive $12.3 million in assets and earning $8.1 million in revenue in 2023,argues that relocating the facility would be prohibitively expensive,estimated at a whopping $1 million due to required electrical and plumbing upgrades.
Frequently Asked Questions: San Francisco Golf Club Maintenance Facility Controversy
Q: Where is the proposed maintenance facility located, and what are the concerns surrounding its proximity to St. Thomas More School?
A: The facility is planned just 40 feet from St. Thomas More School, raising concerns about the safety risks posed by storing fuel and lithium-ion batteries near a school with 300 students. Parents and residents worry about potential fires and hazardous fumes.
Q: What exactly will the facility store, and why are lithium-ion batteries a concern?
A: The facility will store fuel for club vehicles and act as a charging station for golf carts and lawnmowers equipped with lithium-ion batteries. These batteries pose a fire hazard,and San Francisco enacted regulations limiting their storage in residential buildings last year.
Q: Has the planning commission addressed community concerns?
A: Despite community pushback, the planning commission staff surprisingly recommends approving the project. Notably, the existing environmental review document omits any mention of the school’s proximity.
Q: What is the San Francisco Golf Club’s stance on relocating the facility?
A: The club argues that relocation would be prohibitively expensive,estimated at $1 million due to electrical and plumbing upgrades.
Q: What can concerned residents do?
A: Attend the planning commission meeting on february 13, 2025, and voice your concerns. Contact your elected officials and urge them to prioritize the safety of the community over the interests of the golf club.
The fate of the proposed maintenance facility hangs in the balance, highlighting the ongoing tension between wealthy institutions and the needs of surrounding communities.