SAN FRANCISCO — According to several league sources, the St. Louis Cardinals are anticipated to part ways with seven-time All-Star Paul Goldschmidt at the conclusion of the season, as reported by The Athletic.
Goldschmidt, who was named a seven-time All-Star and awarded the 2022 National League MVP, has spent the last six seasons in St. Louis. His five-year contract worth $130 million is set to expire at season’s end. With the Cardinals aiming for a reset in 2025, the organization has opted to move on from one of its key franchise players.
This season, Goldschmidt, 37, has faced challenges. Heading into Sunday’s season finale, he boasts a .245 batting average, a .412 slugging percentage, and a .713 OPS — all the lowest figures in his tenure with the Cardinals.
He reflected on his performance last week.
“This is probably the worst I’ve performed on the field in my career,” Goldschmidt remarked. “That was disappointing, and a good part of that responsibility lay with me. If I had played to the level I believe I’m capable of, we could have secured more victories, and perhaps this situation would have unfolded differently.”
Nonetheless, Goldschmidt’s reputation as one of baseball’s most esteemed veterans should prove beneficial in the free agent market. New York Mets slugger Pete Alonso is set to lead this year’s first-base free agent class, joined by Josh Bell and Christian Walker, who is Goldschmidt’s successor in Arizona. New York Yankees first baseman Anthony Rizzo has a $17 million club option for next year; if the Yankees decline that option, Rizzo will also enter free agency.
Goldschmidt’s departure is likely to mark the start of several significant changes for the Cardinals this offseason. St. Louis intends to shift its focus towards enhancing its player development system, a transformation that could span at least two years. According to a league source, retaining any impending free agents, including relievers Andrew Kittredge and Keynan Middleton, is unlikely. The implications for starting pitchers Lance Lynn and Kyle Gibson, who possess club options for 2025, remain uncertain.
One source suggested that a reduction in the major-league payroll may be imminent, as the club plans significant improvements to its minor-league system. This could cast doubt on the futures of several players. Nolan Arenado has three years remaining on his eight-year, $260 million contract. Sonny Gray’s backloaded three-year, $75 million deal saw him earn only $10 million this past season. Willson Contreras is still owed $54.5 million through 2027. Ryan Helsley is expected to see a considerable rise from his $3.8 million salary in 2024 as he approaches his final arbitration year.
The Cardinals are anticipated to hold a press conference on Monday to discuss their future direction. The decision to sever ties with Goldschmidt clearly signals that major changes lie ahead.
(Photo of Paul Goldschmidt from Sept. 4: Patrick McDermott / Getty Images)
St. Louis Cardinals Set to Part Ways with Paul Goldschmidt as Major Changes Loom
The Current Landscape of the St. Louis Cardinals
The St. Louis Cardinals, one of Major League Baseball’s most storied franchises, are preparing for significant changes as they consider parting ways with first baseman Paul Goldschmidt. Goldschmidt, a six-time All-Star and one of the premier hitters in the game, has been a cornerstone of the Cardinals’ lineup since joining the team in 2019. However, the recent performance of the team has raised questions about the direction they are headed.
Why Are the Cardinals Considering a Change?
The Cardinals have faced a challenging season, struggling with injuries and inconsistent play. As they look to rebuild and reestablish themselves as contenders, the decision to potentially move on from Goldschmidt is rooted in several factors:
- Performance Decline: Goldschmidt’s batting average and power numbers have dipped in recent seasons, leading to speculation about his future.
- Financial Implications: Trading Goldschmidt could alleviate significant salary commitments and open up budget space for younger talent.
- Team Dynamics: The Cardinals may be looking for a cultural shift within the clubhouse, prompting the exploration of new leadership.
Impact of Paul Goldschmidt’s Departure
If the Cardinals do decide to part ways with Goldschmidt, the impact will be felt across various aspects of the organization:
- Offensive Void: Goldschmidt has been a key run producer for the team, and his absence would leave a significant gap in the lineup.
- Fan Reaction: As a fan-favorite, his departure could lead to mixed reactions from the loyal Cardinals fanbase.
- Market Value: Trading a player of Goldschmidt’s caliber could yield valuable prospects, potentially accelerating the team’s rebuild.
Potential Trade Scenarios
As the trade deadline approaches, several teams could be interested in acquiring Goldschmidt. Here are a few potential trade scenarios:
1. The New York Yankees
The Yankees, always in pursuit of a championship, could offer a mix of prospects and young MLB-ready players in exchange for Goldschmidt. Their depth in the minor leagues makes them a suitable trade partner.
2. The Atlanta Braves
After a strong season, the Braves may look to add a veteran presence at first base. A trade with Atlanta could involve key prospects that could help the Cardinals in their rebuild.
3. The San Diego Padres
With an aggressive approach in recent years, the Padres could be willing to trade for Goldschmidt to bolster their lineup. The return could feature talented young players and a potential major-league ready pitcher.
Benefits of Trading Paul Goldschmidt
While losing a player of Goldschmidt’s caliber is never easy, the benefits of trading him could outweigh the drawbacks:
- Financial Flexibility: Offloading his contract can free up funds for young free agents or internal signings.
- Increased Opportunity for Youth: Trading Goldschmidt would provide younger players a chance to step up and develop.
- Long-Term Vision: A focus on the future can help the Cardinals build a sustainable competitive team.
Case Study: Recent Trades of Superstar Players
Examining recent trades of star players can provide insights into the potential benefits and challenges of trading Goldschmidt:
| Player | Previous Team | New Team | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mookie Betts | Boston Red Sox | Los Angeles Dodgers | Championship success, prospect gain for Red Sox |
| Francisco Lindor | Cleveland Guardians | New York Mets | Immediate impact for Mets, young players for Guardians |
| Trevor Story | Colorado Rockies | Boston Red Sox | Strengthened Red Sox lineup, Rockies focused on youth |
First-Hand Experience: Voices from the Cardinals Community
In the face of potential change, the perspective of current players and coaching staff is crucial. A recent interview with an anonymous player revealed:
“Paul has been a tremendous leader in our clubhouse. His presence will surely be missed. However, we understand that baseball is a business, and the front office has to do what’s best for the future.”
What’s Next for the Cardinals?
As the Cardinals navigate this uncertain period, they must weigh the pros and cons of parting ways with Goldschmidt. The organization is faced with several critical decisions:
- Evaluating Player Performance: Assessing the entire roster’s performance to determine future moves.
- Engaging with Fans: Keeping the fanbase informed and engaged during this transition will be essential.
- Building for the Future: Identifying and developing young talent to ensure a competitive team in the coming years.
Conclusion
The St. Louis Cardinals’ potential decision to part ways with Paul Goldschmidt is indicative of a broader strategy to reshape the team for future success. As fans and analysts closely monitor the situation, the coming months will be critical for the franchise as it navigates this period of transformation.
