Codie McLachlan/Getty Images
Defenseman Philip Broberg and forward Dylan Holloway played significant roles in the Oilers’ journey to the Cup Final.
Selected as the eighth overall pick by the Oilers in the 2019 NHL Draft, Broberg spent three seasons fluctuating between the Oilers and their AHL affiliate in Bakersfield. During the 2024 postseason, he participated in only 10 games but made an impact by playing solidly in all seven games of the Cup Final as part of the second pairing.
Holloway, drafted 14th overall by the Oilers in 2020, also divided his time over two seasons between the Oilers and their AHL team. He appeared in 25 postseason games as a third-line winger, contributing five goals and a total of seven points.
As restricted free agents without arbitration rights, both players entered the offseason at a disadvantage in contract negotiations. Consequently, much of the leverage shifted to Oilers management, which allocated a significant portion of its cap space to keep veteran forwards Corey Perry, Adam Henrique, and Mattias Janmark, while also securing wingers Jeff Skinner and Viktor Arvidsson.
Despite expectations for the 23-year-olds to sign short-term, low-cost deals with the prospect of better contracts in the future, the situation changed dramatically. On August 13, the St. Louis Blues disrupted the plans by signing Broberg to a two-year contract averaging $4.6 million annually and Holloway to two years at an average annual value of $2.3 million.
The Oilers could not match these offers, leading to Broberg and Holloway becoming members of the Blues on August 20.
In St. Louis, both players have integrated smoothly. Broberg has registered seven points in his first eight games playing with veteran Justin Faulk, while Holloway has been consistently featured on the third line, scoring three goals and totaling four points in his initial eight games.
Conversely, the Oilers have encountered difficulties, starting the season with a 2-4-1 record. They seem to lack the quickness Holloway provided, and the absence of Broberg’s impressive 6’4″, 212-pound frame and comprehensive defensive skills is felt in their already thin defensive lineup. The loss of these two promising young talents may become a significant issue if they reach their potential in St. Louis.
Oilers’ Departing Young Stars: How Broberg and Holloway’s Moves to St. Louis Could Haunt Edmonton
The Background of Broberg and Holloway
The Edmonton Oilers have long been recognized for their commitment to developing young talent, yet the recent departures of young stars Philip Broberg and Dylan Holloway to the St. Louis Blues have raised eyebrows among fans and analysts alike. Both players were regarded as integral parts of the Oilers’ future, and their relocation could potentially mark a significant turning point for the franchise.
Philip Broberg: A Promising Defenseman
Philip Broberg was drafted 8th overall in the 2019 NHL Draft, showcasing exceptional skating ability and a strong two-way game. His journey through the Oilers’ system demonstrated his potential as a top-pairing defenseman.
– **Strengths**:
– Exceptional skating and agility
- Strong puck-moving abilities
- Solid defensive awareness
– **Career Stats**:
| Season | Games Played | Goals | Assists | Points |
|——–|————–|——-|———|——–|
| 2021-22 | 22 | 1 | 3 | 4 |
| 2022-23 | 40 | 2 | 8 | 10 |
Broberg’s departure leaves a significant gap in the Oilers’ defensive lineup, where his speed and offensive instincts could have complemented established stars like Darnell Nurse and Duncan Keith.
Dylan Holloway: The Forward with Star Potential
Dylan Holloway, selected 14th overall in the 2020 NHL Draft, has been hailed for his versatility and offensive skill. His ability to play both center and wing has made him a valuable asset for the Oilers.
– **Strengths**:
– Strong two-way game
– Excellent vision and playmaking ability
– High hockey IQ
– **Career Stats**:
| Season | Games Played | Goals | Assists | Points |
|——–|————–|——-|———|——–|
| 2021-22 | 31 | 5 | 3 | 8 |
| 2022-23 | 50 | 10 | 12 | 22 |
Holloway’s offensive contributions and work ethic made him a fan favorite, and his loss could hinder the Oilers’ depth scoring moving forward.
The Impact of Their Departures
The departures of Broberg and Holloway could have several immediate and long-term impacts on the Edmonton Oilers.
1. Talent Drain in Key Areas
– **Defense**: Broberg’s speed and puck-moving ability were crucial for the Oilers’ defensive schemes. His absence may force the Oilers to rely on less experienced players or veterans who may not fit their play style as effectively.
– **Scoring Depth**: Holloway’s versatility could have provided the Oilers with much-needed depth scoring. With his departure, the team’s second and third lines may lack the offensive punch required to compete against league rivals.
2. Potential Regret in Player Development
The Oilers have invested significant resources in developing both Broberg and Holloway. Losing them to a division rival raises questions about their player development strategy and whether they can effectively nurture young talent moving forward.
3. Strengthening the Blues
The St. Louis Blues have historically been a competitive team in the NHL, and adding Broberg and Holloway strengthens their roster significantly. The Blues’ ability to integrate these young stars into their lineup could lead to a more potent offensive and defensive presence, potentially making them a formidable opponent for the Oilers.
Benefits of Their New Opportunities in St. Louis
For both Broberg and Holloway, their moves to St. Louis could present valuable opportunities:
– **Increased Playtime**: Both players may find themselves receiving more ice time and critical roles in the Blues’ lineup, allowing them to develop further and take their game to the next level.
– **Mentorship from Veterans**: Joining a team with veteran players like Ryan O’Reilly and Vladimir Tarasenko provides a fantastic learning environment. They can absorb knowledge and skills from experienced players that can significantly enhance their development.
– **Winning Culture**: The Blues have a strong team culture, which could help both players adapt quickly and thrive in a competitive atmosphere.
Case Studies: Historical Departures Impacting Teams
Analyzing past instances where young stars left their teams can provide insight into the potential ramifications of Broberg and Holloway’s departures.
1. Artemi Panarin from Chicago Blackhawks
After leaving the Blackhawks, Panarin blossomed into one of the NHL’s elite forwards. His success serves as a reminder that players can thrive after moving to new environments, which might haunt the Blackhawks as they missed out on his peak years.
2. Jonathan Marchessault from Florida Panthers
The Panthers’ decision to expose Marchessault in the expansion draft led to his acquisition by the Vegas Golden Knights. Marchessault went on to have a standout season, contributing significantly to the Golden Knights’ success, showcasing the pitfalls of underestimating player value.
Practical Tips for the Oilers Moving Forward
As the Oilers navigate the aftermath of Broberg and Holloway’s departures, here are some practical tips to mitigate the impact:
- **Focus on Draft and Development**: Prioritize scouting and developing homegrown talent to fill gaps created by player departures.
– **Enhance Scouting Network**: Invest in a robust scouting network to identify undervalued players in other teams who could fit the Oilers’ system.
– **Evaluate Current Roster**: Assess the current roster and consider trades or signings that could address weaknesses left by departed players.
– **Culture Building**: Foster a culture that encourages young players to develop while promoting a strong work ethic and camaraderie in the locker room.
Conclusion
The shift of Broberg and Holloway to the St. Louis Blues signals a critical moment for the Edmonton Oilers. Their departures could serve as a wake-up call for the franchise, emphasizing the necessity of nurturing and retaining young talent. As the Oilers look to the future, the impact of these moves will be felt for years to come, shaping the trajectory of the team in a highly competitive league.
