SAN FRANCISCO — Just days prior to his dismissal, Farhan Zaidi traveled to Arizona to observe the Giants face off against the Diamondbacks and engage in organizational meetings. It was essential to begin deliberating on significant offseason choices, as initial deadlines would arrive long before top free agents finalize their decisions.
Now, Buster Posey has these responsibilities on his shoulders. Although he cannot influence the first major milestone — Blake Snell’s opt-out, which Snell is expected to exercise — Posey and his chosen general manager must soon determine how much of the 2025 budget they wish to allocate to arbitration-eligible veterans.
The Giants have nearly a month to decide on contract tenders, although the most intriguing decision has already been made. Thairo Estrada was destined to be non-tendered following a difficult season, as the Giants removed him from the 40-man roster entirely in September, making him a free agent at the onset of the offseason.
This situation leaves four veterans, each of whom has made significant contributions while sporting orange and black. Below is an evaluation of what the Giants may opt to do, with projected 2025 salaries sourced from MLB Trade Rumors:
Mike Yastrzemski ($9.5 million):
During his visit to Phoenix, Zaidi was directly queried about Yastrzemski and acknowledged that he has a fondness for the veteran outfielder, indicating that Yastrzemski will indeed return for a seventh season in San Francisco. Posey is likely to share this sentiment.
The new president of baseball operations was part of the lineup when Yastrzemski arrived on the scene in 2019, and they also played together in 2021. While Yastrzemski may never replicate his 2020 performance, he consistently excels in the small details and serves as a positive influence in the clubhouse.
Moreover, contrary to what some may claim on social media, he remains a valuable asset as a right fielder.
Yastrzemski has been named a Gold Glove Award finalist for the second consecutive year and resurrected his season after a challenging April, wrapping up with a 106 wRC+ and 18 home runs. Teams typically value one Win Above Replacement (WAR) around that projected 2025 salary. Yastrzemski just completed a season with a 1.6 WAR, following seasons of 1.5 WAR and 1.6 WAR in 2022 and 2023, respectively.
The Giants possess a clear understanding of what Yastrzemski brings to the table, and this reliability holds value. He complements a roster that is expected to feature Jung Hoo Lee in center and Heliot Ramos in left field. Should Posey decide to make a major addition and secure another outfielder, Yastrzemski would be the perfect fourth option due to his versatility across all three outfield positions. The same applies if talented prospects like Luis Matos or Marco Luciano emerge. If this roster remains intact, the Giants will feel confident with Yastrzemski in right field, which aligns with his own wishes.
“After April, I felt quite frustrated and was eager to bounce back and demonstrate my worth because I love this place. I have no desire to leave for as long as I’m playing,” he stated in September. “I adore the group here, the staff, the front office treats me like family, and they are exceptional. The fans are fantastic and have made it feel like home.”
“My goal is to stay here as long as possible, and I realize that usually hinges on performance. Therefore, I am focused on consistently adding value each day, whether it’s leading in the clubhouse, playing the right way, running hard, or making defensive plays.”
“I aim to showcase my value wherever I can to ensure I stick around for as long as possible.”
Yastrzemski is keen on securing a multi-year contract, and perhaps the Giants will consider this to lower the average annual value slightly. Nonetheless, he is expected to remain in the fold for the upcoming season.
Tyler Rogers ($5.5 million)
Rogers led the National League in appearances for the second time, achieving a 2.82 ERA and 3.57 F
IP. Similar to Yastrzemski, he tends to replicate the same season repeatedly, though this year’s performance had a distinct highlight. Rogers allowed only six walks across 77 appearances and set an MLB record by recording no unintentional walks in his first 35 games. He boasted the lowest walk rate in all of baseball and restricted opponents to the third-lowest average exit velocity.
Generating soft contact while consistently filling the strike zone. Really, it’s hard to ask for more from a reliever.
In 2024, the Giants primarily utilized Rogers as a setup man. However, if Camilo Doval can rediscover his prior form, Rogers becomes an asset that can be deployed in any late-inning situation. He appears to be tireless, and as he approaches his seventh season, he’ll start surpassing some notable names in the franchise’s history.
Rogers requires only four more appearances to overtake Matt Cain, and with his typical productivity, he would become the 15th pitcher in the franchise’s history to achieve 400 career appearances. Should he replicate last season’s 77 appearances, he’ll surpass the records of Jeremy Affeldt and Santiago Casilla.
LaMonte Wade Jr. ($4.7 million)
When examining each player individually, it’s easy to conclude that all four on this list are worth their respective prices. However, there’s also a broader context to consider.
Despite the addition of some young, emerging talents, the Giants must enhance their athleticism and may hesitate to bring back both the 34-year-old Yastrzemski and the 30-year-old Wade, who has faced ongoing lower-body issues. There may also be a sense that they need more output from first base.
The Giants received merely 14 home runs from this position, ranking 28th across the Majors. Their first basemen landed 21st in OPS and 29th in RBI. Posey played much of his career alongside a first baseman (Brandon Belt) known more for his on-base ability than for power, yet this remains a position where the organization can easily seek more offensive strength.
Wade has displayed two distinct performances in recent years. When healthy, he resembles a bit of Juan Soto, drawing deep counts and achieving OBPs over .400. In the first half of this season, he recorded an OBP of .438.
However, when his knee acts up, it presents a significant challenge. In the second half, he posted a slash line of .207/.316/.342.
re-signing Wade makes sense, especially considering future developments. The Giants don’t wish to block first base over the long term as they expect Bryce Eldridge to debut in 2025, but they require a reliable player to manage the position until Eldridge is ready. A one-year commitment to Wade appears to be a solid choice.
Other options—Carlos Santana, Paul Goldschmidt, and others—could also serve as effective transitions to Eldridge. However, even if the Giants secure one of those players, locking up Wade makes sense, allowing for potential positional versatility or a trade opportunity.
Camilo Doval ($4.6 million)
Doval’s season was a complete struggle in nearly every aspect. At just 27, he possesses one of the top right arms in the league and could likely command three times his current salary on a one-year free-agent deal.
This decision is straightforward, and the only discussion regarding Doval involves his initial role in 2025. The Giants currently have a reliable closer in Ryan Walker, but each postseason game reminds them that having an abundance of high-velocity relievers is crucial.
With Doval and Randy Rodriguez, they possess two potentially explosive right-handed setup men. Although Doval may regret not signing a long-term deal following his All-Star season, he remains young and talented enough to reclaim a closing role at some point, allowing him to maximize his earnings once he does hit free agency.
Navigating the Offseason: Key Decisions Ahead for the San Francisco Giants Under Buster Posey
The Legacy of Buster Posey
Buster Posey, one of the most revered figures in San Francisco Giants history, officially stepped down from his playing career in 2021, leaving behind a legacy that includes three World Series championships and an MVP award. As the Giants navigate the offseason with Posey now in a prominent front-office role, there are several critical decisions that will shape the team’s future. This article explores the key areas where the Giants must focus as they look to build a competitive roster.
1. Evaluating the Roster: Players to Keep or Let Go
The first major decision for the Giants this offseason involves evaluating the current roster. With several players hitting free agency and others under contract, it’s essential to weigh the performance, potential, and financial implications of each decision. Here are some critical players to consider:
- Brandon Belt: A veteran leader and first baseman, Belt’s performance will be scrutinized as he is a free agent. Should the Giants retain him for his experience or move on to a younger option?
- Kevin Gausman: After a strong 2021 season, Gausman has become a sought-after pitcher. The Giants must decide whether to extend a qualifying offer or pursue other pitching options.
- Donovan Solano: As a utility player, Solano has been a valuable asset; however, the Giants need to assess if he fits into their future plans.
2. Strengthening the Pitching Rotation
One of the Giants’ top priorities this offseason must be reinforcing their pitching staff. With the ever-important starting rotation needing depth and consistency, the team could consider the following strategies:
Free Agent Targets
Signing a top-tier free agent pitcher can significantly enhance the team’s chances for success. Consider these options:
- Max Scherzer: A three-time Cy Young Award winner, Scherzer’s experience and dominance could elevate the Giants’ pitching rotation.
- Clayton Kershaw: Familiar with the NL West, Kershaw could bring a veteran leadership presence to the clubhouse.
- Robbie Ray: Coming off a Cy Young season, Ray’s ability to generate strikeouts could be a game-changer for the Giants.
Trade Possibilities
If the Giants prefer to pursue trades, they might look at teams with surplus pitching talent. Potential candidates include:
- Boston Red Sox: The Red Sox might be willing to part with some of their younger arms in exchange for offensive prospects.
- Chicago Cubs: With a rebuilding phase underway, the Cubs could offer valuable pitchers in exchange for young talent.
3. Bolstering the Offense
While pitching is crucial, a well-rounded offense is equally important for success. The Giants can explore several avenues to enhance their offensive output:
Identifying Key Free Agents
The free-agent market offers several hitters who could help improve the Giants’ lineup:
- Chris Taylor: A versatile player who can contribute both as a hitter and fielder, Taylor would add depth to the roster.
- Javier Baez: Known for his dynamic play, Baez can bring excitement and consistency to the infield.
- Kyle Schwarber: A power hitter, Schwarber could help the Giants improve their home-run numbers.
Homegrown Talent
The Giants also have the opportunity to utilize their farm system. Players like
- Marco Luciano: As a top prospect, Luciano’s development could provide the Giants with much-needed infielder depth.
- Heliot Ramos: An exciting outfield prospect who could break into the lineup and add speed and power.
4. Leadership and Coaching Staff Decisions
With Buster Posey stepping into his new role, his influence on the coaching staff will be vital. Decisions regarding the current coaching staff can make a significant impact on player development and performance. Some considerations include:
- Retain or Replace: The Giants need to assess whether the current coaching staff effectively supports player development and team performance.
- Integrating New Ideas: Posey’s fresh perspective can help embrace new strategies, especially in analytics and player preparation.
- Strengthening Player Relationships: Building a strong rapport with players can enhance on-field performance and morale.
5. Financial Implications and Budget Management
Budgeting is an essential aspect of offseason planning. The Giants must navigate their financial resources wisely:
Analyzing the Payroll
The Giants need a comprehensive understanding of their payroll commitments, including any long-term contracts. This analysis will inform their spending capabilities during free agency.
Budgeting for Free Agency
Set a realistic budget for free agency to avoid overspending. Prioritize key acquisitions that fit into both the immediate and future goals. The following table illustrates potential areas of expenditure:
| Category | Estimated Cost |
|---|---|
| Top-tier Pitcher | $25M – $35M |
| Offensive Free Agent | $15M – $25M |
| Coaching Staff Changes | $2M – $5M |
6. Engaging with Fans and Community Outreach
As the offseason progresses, maintaining a positive relationship with fans is vital. The Giants should focus on engagement strategies:
- Fan Events: Organize events to engage fans and showcase new signings.
- Social Media Presence: Use social media platforms to keep fans informed and involved.
- Community Programs: Invest in community outreach programs that resonate with local fans, helping to strengthen the franchise’s ties with its supporters.
7. Looking Ahead: Building a Competitive Future
The decisions made during this offseason will set the tone for the upcoming seasons. By focusing on strategic player acquisitions, enhancing coaching methodologies, and fostering community relationships, the San Francisco Giants can build a competitive roster that honors Buster Posey’s legacy while aiming for future success.
