A stunning report reveals that Manchester United is prepared to wait until next summer to entice Liverpool legend Xabi Alonso to Old Trafford, potentially as Erik ten Hag’s successor.
Ten Hag’s role as manager of Manchester United is again under significant scrutiny. With just three victories from the first nine matches, pressure mounts ahead of a crucial fixture against Aston Villa this Sunday.
Sir Jim Ratcliffe, a minority shareholder, is expected to be present at Villa Park, and a loss to Unai Emery’s team could mark Ten Hag’s final game in charge of the Red Devils.
According to an explosive report from Spanish outlet Todofichajes, Manchester United aims to surprise their fierce rivals, Liverpool, by appointing former Reds star Xabi Alonso as Ten Hag’s replacement.
Alonso was a key player for Liverpool from 2004 to 2009, helping the team secure the Champions League (2005) and FA Cup (2006). Earlier in 2024, Liverpool considered Alonso as a successor to Jurgen Klopp, but he opted to stay loyal to Bayer Leverkusen for at least one more season.
However, the report from Spain states that Manchester United is “willing to wait for Xabi Alonso,” hoping to bring him on board at the conclusion of the 2024/25 season.
Alonso, who was instrumental in leading Leverkusen to their first-ever Bundesliga title last season, has been identified as Manchester United’s “top choice.”
READ MORE: Next Manchester United manager: EVERY single option rumored to replace the increasingly under-pressure Ten Hag
Is it possible for Xabi Alonso to join Manchester United?
Should Manchester United choose to wait for Alonso’s arrival next summer, they would need to appoint an interim manager if Ten Hag were to be dismissed mid-season.
In this scenario, a recent update from The Mirror suggests that current assistant manager Ruud van Nistelrooy would step in as interim boss if Ten Hag is let go.
It’s worth mentioning that Todofichajes is not typically regarded as a reliable source for transfer or managerial news.
According to TEAMtalk, Thomas Tuchel is a more likely candidate if Ten Hag is dismissed, with Max Allegri also seen favorably by United executives. Both managers are currently unemployed and available.
Additionally, local options like British coaches Graham Potter, Eddie Howe, and Gareth Southgate are also under serious consideration.
There are significant uncertainties regarding whether Alonso would even be interested in the Manchester United position if it were to be offered to him.
Though it’s early in the season, United currently does not seem poised to qualify for the following year’s Champions League. Furthermore, there has been consistent speculation that Alonso is viewed as a long-term option for Real Madrid when it becomes necessary to replace Carlo Ancelotti.
Analysts critique Manchester United and Ten Hag
In related news, former United coach Benni McCarthy has provided insights into why Jadon Sancho’s move to Chelsea was always probable, while discussing the issues surrounding his difficult stint at Old Trafford.
Pundit Paul Merson has highlighted Ryan Gravenberch to illustrate a key distinction between Liverpool’s manager Arne Slot and Ten Hag.
“Ryan Gravenberch has been outstanding for Liverpool,” Merson mentioned in an interview with Sportskeeda. “Good coaches enhance player performance, which is precisely what Slot has accomplished with Gravenberch this season.
“He appears to be a considerably improved player compared to last year. In contrast, when you look up towards Manchester [United], it’s hard to identify anyone who has developed under Ten Hag.”
Additionally, two Dutch commentators have criticized both Ten Hag and centre-back Matthijs de Ligt, arguing that De Ligt’s career appears to have stagnated, and moving to Manchester United is seen as evidence of this decline.
Ten Hag’s win rate surpasses many
Here’s how Ten Hag’s win percentage compares to that of other Manchester United managers since Ferguson (percentages valid as of October 1).
Manchester United Targets Xabi Alonso as Ten Hag’s Potential Replacement Amid Rising Pressure
Current Situation: Erik ten Hag Under Scrutiny
Manchester United is facing mounting pressure following a series of underwhelming performances in the Premier League. Manager Erik ten Hag’s position has come under scrutiny as fans and pundits alike express concerns over the team’s form. Ten Hag, who took the reins in April 2022, has struggled to replicate the success envisioned by the club’s hierarchy. As a result, the search for a potential successor has begun, with Xabi Alonso emerging as a frontrunner.
Why Xabi Alonso?
Xabi Alonso, currently the manager of Bayer Leverkusen, has garnered attention for his impressive managerial skills in the Bundesliga. His tactical acumen, player management, and ability to inspire a team have made him a valuable asset in the football management landscape. Here’s why United is considering Alonso:
- Proven Track Record: Alonso has successfully transformed Bayer Leverkusen into a competitive side, evident through their impressive performances in domestic and European competitions.
- Understanding of the Premier League: Having played for Liverpool and established himself as a fan favorite, Alonso’s knowledge of the Premier League’s demands is undeniable.
- Winning Mentality: A former player of elite clubs, Alonso carries a winning mentality that could reinvigorate United’s ambitions.
Potential Benefits of Appointing Xabi Alonso
Bringing in Xabi Alonso could yield several benefits for Manchester United:
1. Tactical Innovation
Alonso’s style of play focuses on possession and fluid attacking movement, which could enhance United’s performance on the pitch. His experience in developing tactical systems could help maximize the talents of players like Bruno Fernandes and Marcus Rashford.
2. Player Development
Alonso is known for nurturing young talent, which aligns with United’s philosophy of promoting youth. His ability to improve players could be crucial in revitalizing the squad.
3. Fan Engagement
As a former Premier League star, Alonso could engage the fanbase more effectively than Ten Hag, potentially restoring some of the lost connection between the club and its supporters.
Challenges Faced by Xabi Alonso
Despite the potential advantages, appointing Alonso is not without its challenges:
- Pressure of Expectations: Manchester United is a club with a rich history and high expectations, which could be daunting for a relatively new manager.
- Adapting to a New Environment: Transitioning from Bayer Leverkusen to Manchester United involves significant changes in culture, resource allocation, and player management.
Comparative Analysis: Ten Hag vs. Alonso
| Criteria | Erik ten Hag | Xabi Alonso |
|---|---|---|
| Previous Experience | Ajax, Utrecht | Bayer Leverkusen |
| Playing Style | Possession-based, attacking | Fluid, adaptable tactics |
| Club Legacy | Struggles to meet expectations | Former Premier League star |
| Player Development | Mixed results | Strong focus on youth |
Fan Reactions and Media Speculations
The media has been buzzing with speculation surrounding Alonso’s potential move to Manchester United. Fans have expressed mixed feelings, with some supporting the idea of fresh leadership, while others remain loyal to Ten Hag despite recent struggles. Social media platforms have become a hotspot for discussions on a possible managerial change.
What Are Fans Saying?
On platforms like Twitter, hashtags such as #AlonsoToUnited have gained traction, indicating a growing interest in the former midfielder as a managerial candidate. Supporters appreciate his playing career and see his managerial potential as a reason for optimism.
Case Studies: Successful Managerial Transitions
To understand the potential impact of a managerial change, let’s look at a few successful transitions in recent football history:
1. Jürgen Klopp at Liverpool
After a challenging start, Klopp transformed Liverpool into one of the top clubs in Europe. His understanding of the Premier League and ability to motivate players were key to his success.
2. Pep Guardiola at Manchester City
Guardiola’s tactical innovations and emphasis on possession play revolutionized Manchester City, leading them to multiple titles. His approach showcases the importance of a strong tactical vision in modern football.
Practical Tips for Manchester United’s Management
If Manchester United decides to pursue Xabi Alonso, there are several practical steps they should consider:
- Gradual Transition: If Ten Hag is to be replaced, a gradual transition could help mitigate disruptions within the squad.
- Clear Objectives: Establishing clear objectives for Alonso from day one will be essential in aligning the squad’s goals with the club’s ambitions.
- Support for Player Development: Providing resources for Alonso to develop young players is crucial, as this aligns with the club’s historical approach to nurturing talent.
Conclusion: A Look Ahead
As Manchester United navigates this challenging period, the potential appointment of Xabi Alonso could signify a new chapter for the club. With his managerial prowess and deep understanding of the Premier League, he may be the catalyst needed to restore United’s status among the elite in football.
