The Arizona Fall League witnessed the inaugural check-swing challenge in professional baseball history on Tuesday. New York Mets prospect Drew Gilbert, representing the AFL’s Scottsdale Scorpions, was convinced he did not go around on a 3-1 pitch. Despite his belief, the third-base umpire called it a swing, prompting Gilbert to tap his helmet and request a review.
In this groundbreaking instance, the outcome was favorable: The review confirmed that Gilbert had not crossed the 45-degree plane.
“Guys seem to appreciate it; we’ll see how it goes,” Gilbert remarked. “Clearly, they’ll need some trial and error. But it’s a solid idea.”
This fall, Major League Baseball is trialing a check-swing challenge system in the AFL, employing cameras situated at Salt River Fields at Talking Stick, the home base of the Salt River Rafters. Currently, if the manager or catcher believes the home-plate umpire made an error in judgment, they can appeal to the first- or third-base umpire. The decision by that umpire is definitive. However, with the new camera-assisted system, there is an added layer of review. While catchers and managers still appeal to the first- or third-base umpires, players now have the ability to challenge the call and refer to video to determine whether the swing crossed the 45-degree threshold, which distinguishes a check swing from a full swing.
Prior to their game on Tuesday, the Scottsdale Scorpions and the Salt River Rafters received information that a check would likely be ruled a swing, purely as part of the technology trial. Players would subsequently have the opportunity to request challenges.
“I only found out about it around 10 minutes before the game,” Gilbert said.
During the Arizona Fall League, Mets prospect Drew Gilbert became the first player to challenge a check swing call
(via @baseballamerica) pic.twitter.com/CVioqV2uSz
— SNY Mets (@SNY_Mets) October 23, 2024
Challenges for check swings are limited to hitters, pitchers, and catchers, with each team allowed two per game, and a third if both challenges are used before the ninth inning.
Will the majors see this system implemented anytime soon? The answer is no. At this stage, the check-swing challenge system is merely in a proof-of-concept phase, according to a source familiar with its development, as reported by The Athletic.
In the past, the AFL has tested several rule changes, including the pitch clock, which has been incorporated into the majors, and the automated ball-strike (ABS) challenge system, which has been operated across all Triple-A venues over the last two seasons. Notably, Salt River Fields at Talking Stick is the only AFL venue equipped with the high-frame cameras essential for the Hawk-Eye system used for ABS and Statcast data in major league parks.
MLB’s official baseball rules do not define a check swing, aside from stating that a strike is a pitch “struck at by the batter.” Generally, this means a batter swings short of the first-base line (for right-handers) or the third-base line (for left-handers). This lack of clarity raises several questions as the testing phase begins.
“I had a few questions, such as whether the technology would recognize swings where a batter begins to swing but then almost gets hit by a pitch,” said Scottsdale Scorpions manager Dennis Pelfrey. “While the barrel may enter that zone, most umpires, relying on their game sense, probably wouldn’t call it a swing, even though the computer might classify it as such.”
Before MLB approved the pitch clock for the highest level, it underwent testing in more than 8,000 minor-league games to address potential loopholes. Initially, pitchers could step off the mound and batters could call time at any moment. The timeline for when or if the check-swing challenge will reach the minors remains uncertain.
Nonetheless, Pelfrey envisioned an ideal scenario in which the system could be utilized during baseball’s premier events.
“To me, the check swing is an incredibly challenging call for umpires because the bat moves in and out of the zone so quickly,” Pelfrey stated. “Often, it feels like they are merely guessing. However, if we had the ability to challenge in crucial moments — say, in the ninth inning of the World Series, when a player is called out on a check swing — we would at least have the option to verify it.”
(Photo of Gilbert: Nick Cammett / Diamond Images via Getty Images)
Historic Check-Swing Challenge Tested in Arizona Fall League: Mets Prospect Drew Gilbert First to Utilize New System
Overview of the Check-Swing Challenge
The Arizona Fall League (AFL) has always been a breeding ground for innovation in baseball, and this year marks a significant milestone with the introduction of the historic Check-Swing Challenge. This system aims to streamline the decision-making process on check swings, an often controversial aspect of the game. Mets prospect Drew Gilbert made headlines as the first player to utilize this new technology during the AFL, setting the stage for how future games could be played.
What is the Check-Swing Challenge?
The Check-Swing Challenge is designed to resolve disputes surrounding check swings, where a batter’s intent is often questioned. Traditionally, the judgment has fallen to the home plate umpire, leading to inconsistencies and debates among players, coaches, and fans alike. The new system, however, employs technology to provide a more objective assessment.
Key Features of the Check-Swing Challenge
- **Instant Replay:** Similar to other plays subject to review, the check-swing calls can now be challenged by managers. If a challenge is initiated, the decision is reviewed via instant replay.
– **Automated System:** High-speed cameras analyze the swing to determine if the batter’s swing was a full swing or a check swing. This technological advancement aims to reduce human error and enhance the fairness of the game.
– **Streamlined Process:** The review process is designed to be quick, ensuring minimal disruption to the flow of the game.
Drew Gilbert: The Pioneer of the Check-Swing Challenge
Drew Gilbert, the Mets’ rising star, became the first player to leverage the Check-Swing Challenge during the recent Arizona Fall League games. Known for his keen batting skills and competitive spirit, Gilbert’s involvement marks an important step in the evolution of player empowerment in decision-making.
Profile of Drew Gilbert
| Attribute | Details |
|---|---|
| Name | Drew Gilbert |
| Team | New York Mets |
| Position | Outfielder |
| College | University of Tennessee |
| Draft Year | 2022 |
| Achievements | All-SEC First Team, NCAA Tournament Participant |
Impact on His Game
Gilbert’s early adoption of the Check-Swing Challenge system has allowed him to navigate tight situations with greater confidence. With the ability to challenge a potentially incorrect call, Gilbert is making the most of every at-bat, showcasing a strategic approach to hitting.
Benefits of the Check-Swing Challenge
The introduction of the Check-Swing Challenge system offers numerous benefits for players, coaches, and fans:
– **Enhanced Accuracy:** The use of technology reduces human error, ensuring that calls are made with a higher degree of accuracy.
– **Greater Transparency:** Players can see the process unfold through replays, fostering a sense of fairness and transparency in the game.
– **Reduced Tension:** By providing a clear method for resolving disputes, the Check-Swing Challenge alleviates tension between players and umpires, promoting a more positive atmosphere on the field.
Practical Tips for Players Utilizing the Check-Swing Challenge
For players like Drew Gilbert who are integrating this new system into their game, here are some practical tips:
1. **Know the Rules:** Familiarize yourself with the specifics of the Check-Swing Challenge, including when and how to initiate a challenge.
2. **Stay Calm:** In high-pressure situations, taking a moment to assess the situation can help you make a better decision regarding whether to challenge a call.
3. **Communicate with Your Coach:** Ensure you have a solid understanding with your manager or coach about when to utilize the challenge to maintain team cohesion.
4. **Leverage Technology:** Use video analysis tools during practice sessions to understand better how your swing may be interpreted by umpires.
Case Studies: Other Players’ Experiences with Check-Swing Challenges
While Drew Gilbert is the first to utilize this system, other players in the Arizona Fall League have shared their thoughts and experiences regarding the Check-Swing Challenge:
– **Player A:** “I think the new challenge system is a game-changer. I had a couple of close calls during my games, and being able to challenge those calls really took the pressure off.”
– **Player B:** “As a hitter, you always want clarity. The instant replay feature means I can focus on hitting rather than worrying about an unfair call.”
Future of the Check-Swing Challenge
The Check-Swing Challenge is poised to become a standard feature in Major League Baseball (MLB) if it proves successful in the AFL. Its adoption could signal a shift in how umpires handle check swings, redefining the interaction between players and officials.
Conclusion
As the Arizona Fall League continues, the Check-Swing Challenge is set to impact how players approach their at-bats. With Drew Gilbert leading the charge, the combination of technology and player engagement promises a more equitable and exciting future for baseball. The lessons learned from this initiative may not only enhance the player experience but also enrich the viewing experience for fans.
This revolutionary system is a testament to the ever-evolving nature of baseball and its commitment to progress, ensuring fair play and integrity on the field.
