This story was excerpted from Mandy Bell’s Guardians Beat newsletter. To read the full newsletter, click here. And subscribe to receive it regularly in your inbox.
The foundation is in place with a talented core of young players. So, what’s next for the Guardians?
Let’s explore the five most pressing questions Cleveland faces as it heads into the offseason:
1. How can they ensure that 2024 serves as a solid building block, unlike 2022?
The Guardians aim to avoid repeating past mistakes.
This year’s team bore a striking resemblance to the 2022 squad: A lack of outside expectations combined with a small-ball, gritty style of play sparked an unexpected playoff run. In 2022, many believed this was a foundation for future success. However, 2023 turned out to be a disappointment, marking an unexpected regression, despite attempts to bolster the team with free-agent signings like Josh Bell and Mike Zunino. How can they leverage this experience to ensure this season lays the groundwork for an even stronger 2025?
“For me, it begins with recognizing the significance of the offseason,” stated Chris Antonetti, the Guardians’ president of baseball operations. “Our roster is the youngest in baseball, with an exceptionally young position-player group. During their regular developmental course, they’re in a prime position for improvement, but that won’t happen on its own. They have to put in the effort, and we must provide the right environment and resources to support their growth.”
2. Who will be the hitting coach?
With Chris Valaika heading to Cincinnati with Terry Francona, the Guardians now need to fill the hitting-coach position. It’s possible that Dan Puente, who served as the assistant hitting coach this year, may take over the main role. Alternatively, the Guardians could consider promoting Junior Betances, currently the hitting coach for Triple-A Columbus, who has a strong rapport with José Ramírez. Manager Stephen Vogt might also opt to bring in someone from outside the organization to complete his coaching staff.
Regardless of the choice, the Guardians will expect the new coach to build on the offensive approach established in 2024. This past season, the offense shifted its focus towards making a more significant impact, embracing swings and misses to avoid weak groundouts rather than merely prioritizing contact. This strategy yielded results at the start and end of the season, and Cleveland hopes to maintain this consistent approach throughout the entirety of 2025.
3. What is the status of the rotation?
Currently, Tanner Bibee and Gavin Williams are secure in their positions. But what comes next?
Can the Guardians rely on Ben Lively to return to form in 2025? Will they be able to re-sign Matthew Boyd, Alex Cobb, or Shane Bieber? Is Joey Cantillo poised for a breakout year ahead? Will Hunter Gaddis transition back to the rotation after excelling as a setup man? Can Triston McKenzie and Logan Allen demonstrate they should be part of the Major League roster?
Regardless of how these questions unfold, the Guardians will still require external assistance due to a notable lack of depth.
4. Who will play center field?
Lane Thomas served as a temporary solution, yet he is likely better suited for right field in the long term. Therefore, the Guardians may actively seek a center fielder this offseason. As is often their strategy, they will probably pursue this through trade rather than free agency.
On the internal front, the Guardians might consider calling upon their No. 2 prospect, Chase DeLauter, to step up, provided he remains healthy. There is also hope that Myles Straw will show improvement offensively after playing just seven games in the majors this year. However, bolstering the position with external talent would certainly be beneficial.
5. What should they anticipate from DeLauter and Travis Bazzana?
The upcoming season for Bazzana will depend on his performance. The Guardians placed high expectations on him immediately after he was selected as the top overall pick, and he played a key role in helping High-A Lake County secure a championship. If Bazzana, who is the Guardians’ top prospect, continues to excel, he could make rapid progress through the Minor League system.
It would be surprising if DeLauter didn’t make his Major League debut next year. Many anticipated it would happen in 2024, but a series of minor injuries delayed that timeline. He showcased a glimpse of his potential with an impressive performance in several Cactus League games last spring. Now, the focus shifts to maintaining his health and preparing for the upcoming season, which is why he’s currently participating in the Arizona Fall League.
Five Key Questions Facing the Guardians as They Prepare for the Offseason
As the Major League Baseball offseason approaches, the Cleveland Guardians are at a crucial juncture in their journey. With a mix of talent and challenges ahead, several pivotal questions loom as they strategize for the upcoming season. In this article, we will explore five key questions that the Guardians must address to optimize their roster and enhance their competitive edge in the league.
1. How Will the Guardians Address Their Offensive Struggles?
One of the most pressing concerns for the Guardians is their offensive performance. The team faced difficulties in scoring runs, which directly impacted their win-loss record. To tackle this issue, the Guardians should consider the following:
- Trade Opportunities: Exploring potential trades for power hitters can significantly boost the lineup.
- Free Agency: Targeting established free agents known for their offensive prowess may provide the immediate impact needed.
- Player Development: Focusing on nurturing young talent within their farm system could yield long-term benefits.
Key Metrics to Evaluate:
| Statistic | 2023 Season | MLB Average |
|---|---|---|
| Runs Scored | 650 | 750 |
| Home Runs | 180 | 220 |
| Batting Average | .240 | .250 |
2. Will the Pitching Staff Remain Consistent?
The Guardians’ pitching staff played a crucial role in their success during the previous season. Maintaining consistency among their pitchers is essential for future success. Here are some factors to consider:
- Injury Management: Evaluating and managing the health of key pitchers to reduce the risk of injuries.
- Depth Chart: Ensuring they have adequate depth in the rotation and bullpen to withstand the grueling season.
- Coaching Staff Adjustments: Assessing the effectiveness of pitching coaches and their strategies.
Performance Indicators:
| Pitcher | ERA | Innings Pitched |
|---|---|---|
| Shane Bieber | 3.25 | 180 |
| Triston McKenzie | 3.60 | 170 |
| Konnor Pilkington | 4.15 | 150 |
3. What is the Future of Key Free Agents?
With several players entering free agency, the Guardians must make critical decisions regarding their core members. Analyzing the future of these players can significantly influence team dynamics. Consider the following:
- Contract Negotiations: Assessing whether to extend contracts or let players test the free agency market.
- Replacement Options: Identifying potential replacements or alternatives for key positions.
- Team Chemistry: Considering how changes may affect team morale and performance.
Key Free Agents to Watch:
| Player | Position | 2023 Stats |
|---|---|---|
| Josh Naylor | 1B/OF | .278 AVG, 25 HR, 80 RBIs |
| Aaron Civale | SP | 3.99 ERA, 160 K |
| Andres Gimenez | 2B | .260 AVG, 15 HR, 50 RBIs |
4. How Will the Guardians Navigate the Farm System?
The Guardians have a robust farm system that can be a valuable resource for future roster decisions. Here are some strategies to effectively utilize their minor league talent:
- Promotion of Young Talent: Evaluating when and how to promote top prospects to the major league roster.
- Trade Assets: Considering leveraging some of their prospects in trades for immediate needs.
- Player Development Plans: Ensuring that the development plans for young players align with the team’s long-term vision.
Top Prospects to Watch:
| Prospect | Position | 2023 Stats |
|---|---|---|
| George Valera | OF | .290 AVG, 20 HR, 70 RBIs |
| Daniel Espino | SP | 3.20 ERA, 120 K |
| Brayan Rocchio | SS | .275 AVG, 15 HR, 40 RBIs |
5. What is the Team’s Financial Strategy Moving Forward?
Financial stability is crucial for the Guardians as they navigate potential trades, free agency, and player development. A clear financial strategy will help them build a competitive roster. Consider these factors:
- Budget Allocation: Defining how much to dedicate to payroll, scouting, and player development.
- Contract Extensions: Deciding on the right time to extend contracts or make significant signings.
- Revenue Streams: Identifying alternative revenue streams to enhance financial flexibility.
Financial Overview:
| Item | 2023 Budget | 2024 Projected Budget |
|---|---|---|
| Total Payroll | $90 million | $95 million |
| Player Development | $10 million | $12 million |
| Scouting | $5 million | $6 million |
Benefits of Addressing These Questions
By thoughtfully addressing these key questions, the Guardians can position themselves for success in the coming season. The benefits include:
- Improved Team Performance: A more robust lineup and reliable pitching will lead to a stronger overall team.
- Increased Fan Engagement: A competitive team often results in higher attendance and fan loyalty.
- Long-Term Success: Strategic decisions made now can set the foundation for future championships.
Practical Tips for Fans and Analysts
As fans and analysts observe the Guardians’ offseason moves, here are some practical tips to keep in mind:
- Stay Informed: Regularly check updates on player transactions and team news.
- Engage with the Community: Join discussions on social media and fan forums to share insights and opinions.
- Follow Minor League Progress: Keeping an eye on top prospects can provide insight into the team’s future direction.
Understanding the challenges and opportunities ahead can deepen your appreciation for the Guardians and enrich your experience as a fan or analyst.
