CLEVELAND — On Thursday night, the New York Yankees showcased an incredible comeback that, for nearly an hour, appeared to defy the norms of sloppy baseball, placing them just one victory away from the World Series in an electrifying and unexpected manner.
Trailing by two runs with two outs in the eighth inning against the Cleveland Guardians, the Yankees faced the daunting challenge of overcoming Emmanuel Clase, Major League Baseball’s top closer. Clase had allowed only five earned runs during the regular season across 74 appearances. The Detroit Tigers managed to score against him once in the AL Division Series, only for him to rebound strongly in subsequent multi-inning stints. It seemed nearly impossible to reverse the Yankees’ deficit.
Editor’s Picks
2 Related
However, that changed when Aaron Judge launched a piercing low line drive that flew just over the right-field wall, resulting in a tying two-run homer. Within two minutes, Giancarlo Stanton followed suit, hammering a slider over the center-field wall, transforming it into back-to-back home runs and granting the Yankees a one-run lead. The team erupted from the dugout in jubilation, having vanquished the formidable Clase.
Following that, what began as a peculiar game turned into one of the most unforgettable matches in recent postseason history, culminating in a 7-5 victory for Cleveland in 10 innings.
“That was an incredible game on both sides. All the emotions, the ups and downs, back and forth—every feeling was experienced by everyone involved,” Guardians manager Stephen Vogt remarked. “If there’s an emotion to be felt, we all experienced it from both sides.”
A roller coaster. A heavyweight bout. Insert any cliché here. It epitomized classic baseball. Here are six major moments from the game—accompanied by win probabilities before each turning point—to showcase the chaos.
Top of the eighth inning, two outs
Cleveland leads 3-1
Win probability: 93.2% Cleveland
Aaron Judge’s game-tying home run was just the beginning of this intense contest. AP Photo/Jeff Roberson
Just prior to Judge’s appearance against Clase, Guardians right-hander Hunter Gaddis seemed to intentionally pitch around Soto. Gaddis, who posted a 5% walk rate during the regular season—ranked 14th among relievers—issued a four-pitch walk to Soto, with none of the pitches coming particularly close to the strike zone. This prompted Vogt to switch Gaddis out for Clase.
Yankees manager Aaron Boone insisted that Gaddis was not deliberately avoiding Soto. Judge stated he had “no idea” about the intention. Regardless, this sequence led to a highly anticipated confrontation: Judge versus Clase. Raw power against raw power. The best hitter in the world versus the leading reliever.
The initial exchanges leaned in Clase’s favor. The right-hander quickly took control with a cutter down the middle that Judge fouled off, followed by a cutter away that Judge swung through. Judge then watched a 99 mph cutter that was far off the plate before Clase hit the outside corner with another 99 mph cutter.
“He just stayed with it,” Stanton remarked about Judge’s performance. “It was impressive. It wasn’t a bad pitch; it was low and away, right on the edge. And he simply did what he does best.”
What Judge accomplished was a solid barrel on the baseball. It soared at 109.9 mph from the bat and landed 356 feet away, just over the
The ball smacked against the wall and ricocheted into the stands as Judge dashed towards first base. The game was tied.
“I thought it was a low pitch,” Judge remarked. “So my initial instinct was to get to second base. I was hoping Juan could score or at least be on third. But my priority was to reach second for Big G coming up in that situation.”
Top of the eighth inning, two outs
Tie game 3-3
Win probability: 59.9% Cleveland
Stanton, much like his teammate, found himself down 0-2. He fouled off a slider registering 91 mph, swung and missed a cutter at 100 mph, and then fouled a cutter straight down the middle. Just two pitches later, he fouled off a 93 mph slider that sailed over the plate. Those two pitches lingered in his mind.
Best of 2024 MLB Playoffs
Schoenfield: Top bullpen ever? (ESPN+) »
Gonzalez: How Freeman fought to NLCS »
Doolittle: Early NLCS lessons (ESPN+) »
Castillo: Judge eyes October redemption »
<p"He was throwing a lot of cutters and sliders inside, so it was crucial to get one out over the plate," Stanton explained. "I missed a couple of good pitches before finally connecting with the third one."
The decisive pitch came on the seventh throw of his at-bat; a slider at 90 mph that caught too much of the plate. Stanton attacked with an 85 mph swing—the hardest contact made by either team on that Thursday. The ball rocketed off his bat at 106.1 mph, sailing 390 feet away from home plate.
“I think I threw a fierce right fist pump, feeling fired up,” Boone said. “But you’re right there in the game. … You focus on what’s next. Still, you can’t help but feel the energy from a couple of hits like that.”
Suddenly, the Yankees found themselves in the lead. This marked the first occasion in 326 career appearances, including postseason games, that Clase allowed multiple home runs in a single game. New York stood just three outs away from inching closer to its first World Series appearance in 15 years. The shift was remarkable, and it had only just begun.
Bottom of the ninth inning, two outs
Yankees lead 5-3
Win probability: 98.5% New York
Luke Weaver, tasked with a four-out save, had navigated a risky two-on, two-out situation in the eighth by striking out David Fry. Following an error by Anthony Rizzo that opened the bottom of the ninth, he initiated a slick 1-6-3 double play, stifling Cleveland’s surge.
Weaver sat just one out away from securing his fourth postseason save of four or more outs. It seemed almost certain when he quickly moved ahead 0-2 against Lane Thomas after the double play. However, he lost his momenta abruptly. The next three pitches were lackluster, allowing Thomas to work the count full. On the sixth pitch of the at-bat, a 95-mph fastball down and in was hooked off the tall left field wall by Thomas.
<p"You find yourself at 0-2, and sometimes you try to do too much," Weaver admitted. "Thomas had a quality at-bat, and the moment started to feel a bit too big. I just needed to step back, but tonight, I didn't quite have the execution required in that moment."
Bottom of the ninth inning, two outs
Yankees lead 5-3
Win probability: 95.4% New York
After the game, Vogt was clear about his rationale for sending Jhonkensy Noel to pinch hit for Daniel Schneemann: “He was brought in to hit a homer,” Vogt stated. “That was our intent.” And sure enough, the man known as “Big Christmas” delivered.
After taking an uninhibited pitch well outside the strike zone, Noel seized on a juicy changeup that landed right over the plate and left no doubt. He effortlessly flipped his bat aside the moment he made contact, tying the game. Chaos erupted around him. For the time being, he had effectively saved the Guardians’ season.
A dominant bullpen has propelled Cleveland towards a showdown.
with the Yankees — but can it lead to a World Series championship?
David Schoenfield (ESPN+)
“I truly felt I let down both the team and myself,” Weaver expressed. “Baseball is unpredictable, and these things happen. A slight twist of an arm feels particularly devastating. We’re still in a solid position and feel a bit of momentum, but the other team earned it. It was a wild game, the bats were on fire, and the ball was flying out of the park.”
Since September 2, Weaver had not given up a home run or multiple runs, marking his last outing prior to assuming the role of the Yankees’ primary closer.
“It stings a bit more,” Weaver admitted. ”It’s tough knowing how hard the team fought to reach that point in the game. It hurts even more thinking about how we were at 0-2, just one pitch away after a significant double play. Yeah, it’s all disappointing. The pain comes from how close we were; a 3-0 lead would have been massive. But that’s just how life goes. I’ve experienced enough failures to understand that it doesn’t always unfold as we hope.”
Top of the 10th inning, one out
Tie game, 5-5
Win probability: 50.8% New York
The Yankees threatened to quickly reclaim the lead when Stanton drew a one-out walk, setting the stage for Jazz Chisholm Jr., who had successfully walked and singled in his two previous at-bats. This time, the Yankees’ third baseman hit a grounder into the hole at second base, seemingly destined to roll through the infield.
However, Guardians second baseman Andrés Giménez, moving to his left, somehow managed to snag the ball in shallow right field, spun around, and made a remarkable leaping throw while falling onto his backside. The throw one-hopped to first baseman Josh Naylor, who stretched his limits with his left foot merely grazing first base to complete the astonishing out.
The play evoked memories of the types Hall of Famer Roberto Alomar made during his three-season tenure as Cleveland’s second baseman at the start of the century, and it effectively halted the Yankees’ rally.
“Andrés Giménez is the best infielder in the world,” Vogt praised. “He has been and will continue to be. It feels like he makes jaw-dropping plays every single day.”
Bottom of the 10th inning, two outs
Tie game, 5-5
Win probability: 62.7% Cleveland
After 3 hours and 52 minutes, the night concluded when Cleveland’s Fry crushed a 1-2 sinker mistake left up by Yankees reliever Clay Holmes over the plate, sending the ball into the stands beyond the left-field wall.
LCS predictions: Who will advance?
Only four teams remain. Here’s our take on who will progress to the World Series — plus a look at how our playoff predictions have panned out so far.
Predictions »
Series keys: ALCS | NLCS
“I just told God, ‘Hey, man, take this,'” Fry stated. “It’s a tough matchup. I tried to enjoy it. I fell behind in the count and then got a pitch up in the zone, and fortunately, it sailed out.”
Up until that moment, the Yankees held a remarkable 196-1 record in their postseason history when leading by multiple runs in the ninth inning or later, as per ESPN Research. Their only loss in such situations previously? Game 3 of the 2022 ALDS against … the Guardians.
“We’re meant to go out there and do our jobs,” Holmes remarked. “That’s our role, to go out there and shut things down. Our hitters set us up well, and we simply didn’t execute our pitches. But we expect to go out there and keep them scoreless.”
This marked Fry’s second postseason home run, and both have been pivotal. The first was a go-ahead, two-run shot in Game 4 of the ALDS against the Detroit Tigers while the Guardians faced elimination. That homer sparked a turnaround in the Guardians’ season, allowing them to advance another round. Time will reveal if Thursday’s performance will…
do the same.
Drama Unfolds: Yankees’ Heart-Stopping Comeback Falls Short in Historic ALCS Thriller Against Guardians
The American League Championship Series (ALCS) has always been a stage for unforgettable moments, and the latest showdown between the New York Yankees and the Cleveland Guardians was no exception. In a thrilling contest filled with nail-biting action and high stakes, the Yankees staged a heart-stopping comeback, only to fall short in a dramatic finale. This article delves into the riveting details of this historic game, analyzing key moments, player performances, and the implications for both teams.
Game Overview: A Clash of Titans
As the Yankees faced off against the Guardians, the stakes could not have been higher. The series was level, and both teams were eager to seize the opportunity to advance to the World Series. The atmosphere was electric, with fans from both sides filling the stadium, each cheering their team on to victory.
Key Game Moments
- Early Dominance by the Guardians: The Guardians took an early lead with a stunning home run by José Ramírez in the second inning, sending shockwaves through the Yankees’ lineup.
- Yankees’ Late-Game Surge: In the fifth inning, the Yankees rallied back with a two-run single from Aaron Judge, igniting hope among their fans.
- Extra Innings Drama: A tense ninth inning saw the Yankees tie the game, pushing it into extra innings and raising the stakes even higher.
- Guardians Seal the Deal: A clutch hit from rookie sensation Steven Kwan in the tenth inning ultimately propelled the Guardians to victory.
Player Highlights: The Stars of the Show
This game was a showcase of talent, with several players stepping up to the plate and delivering memorable performances that will be talked about for years to come.
New York Yankees
| Player | Position | Performance |
|---|---|---|
| Aaron Judge | RF | 2 hits, 3 RBIs |
| Gleyber Torres | 2B | 1 hit, 1 run scored |
| Gerrit Cole | SP | 6.2 innings, 8 strikeouts |
Cleveland Guardians
| Player | Position | Performance |
|---|---|---|
| José Ramírez | 3B | 1 home run, 2 RBIs |
| Steven Kwan | LF | 2 hits, game-winning RBI |
| Shane Bieber | SP | 7 innings, 10 strikeouts |
Strategic Insights: Analyzing the Game’s Turning Points
The game’s outcome hinged on strategic decisions made by both managers. From pitching changes to batting orders, every choice played a crucial role in the high-stakes environment.
Managerial Decisions
- Yankees’ Bullpen Management: Manager Aaron Boone opted to utilize various relievers to navigate the Guardians’ lineup. However, the choice to bring in Jonathan Loáisiga proved risky, as it resulted in the decisive run scored by the Guardians.
- Guardians’ Defensive Strategy: Terry Francona’s decision to shift the outfield in the eleventh inning showcased the Guardians’ commitment to defense, which ultimately prevented additional runs from scoring.
Fan Reactions: The Pulse of the Game
Fans are the lifeblood of any sport, and the reactions to this thrilling game reflected the deep passion associated with baseball. Social media buzzed with excitement, despair, and everything in between. Below are some highlights from fans across platforms:
Social Media Buzz
- Twitter: “#YankeesNation is heartbroken but proud of the fight! Let’s regroup for next season!”
- Instagram: Fans shared photos of their game-day experiences, showcasing the electric atmosphere filled with Yankees and Guardians gear.
- Facebook: “This was one of the best playoff games I’ve ever seen. Can’t wait for next season!”
Historical Context: Yankees vs. Guardians Rivalry
The Yankees and Guardians have a storied history in the playoffs. This latest chapter adds another layer to their rivalry, marked by dramatic plays and unforgettable moments. Here’s a brief look at their playoff history:
| Year | Outcome | Notable Players |
|---|---|---|
| 1997 | Yankees won ALDS | Derek Jeter, Bernie Williams |
| 2007 | Guardians won ALDS | C.C. Sabathia, Grady Sizemore |
| 2023 | Guardians won ALCS | José Ramírez, Aaron Judge |
Benefits of Following Baseball Playoffs
Engaging with baseball playoffs, particularly the ALCS, offers numerous benefits for fans:
- Community Engagement: Baseball brings people together, fostering community bonds through shared experiences and fandom.
- Entertainment: The excitement of playoff baseball offers thrilling moments and unforgettable memories.
- Appreciation for the Sport: Watching high-stakes games deepens understanding and appreciation for baseball strategies and player skills.
Practical Tips for Enjoying Postseason Baseball
To make the most out of your postseason baseball experience, consider these practical tips:
- Watch with Friends: Gather fellow fans to enhance the experience with camaraderie and spirited discussions.
- Stay Updated: Follow reliable sports news sources for real-time updates on player performances and game strategies.
- Engage on Social Media: Join the conversation during games to share thoughts, reactions, and connect with other fans.
First-Hand Experience: A Fan’s Perspective
As a fan who attended the ALCS thriller, the atmosphere was nothing short of electric. The tension in the air intensified with every pitch, and the collective gasps from the crowd during pivotal moments created a sense of unity. It was a reminder of why we love this game—its unpredictability and the sheer thrill of competition. The heartache felt after the Yankees’ loss was palpable, but the memories created will last a lifetime.
