The ongoing deadlock between the newly established Chicago Sports Network and Comcast has left Blackhawks fan and Xfinity customer Bailey Coleman in a frustrating situation.
Quite literally.
As the NHL season commenced this month without a carriage agreement between her cable provider and CHSN — the newly designated broadcast home for the Hawks, Bulls, and White Sox — the 25-year-old retail worker from Lake Zurich purchased an antenna for her smart TV. However, she described the experience as “a nightmare.”
“I’ve tried it on every TV, and while I can receive some channels via the antenna, none of them are for the Blackhawks games,” Coleman explained. CHSN has successfully partnered with WJYS to air its content on digital channels 62.2 and 62.3.
“It’s either static or a blue screen that says, ‘Weak signal,’” she added.
Many residents in the Chicago area echo her frustrations.
Some viewers, particularly those with older televisions, have found themselves needing to purchase new receiver boxes to get a clear picture, an issue that CHSN has addressed on its website. Others have stated they refuse to spend any more money on their beloved sports teams.
Since NBC Sports Chicago, the previous network home for the Hawks, Bulls, and Sox, ceased operations on September 30, viewers have been left in a state of uncertainty with the launch of CHSN on October 1.
Negotiations between CHSN and Comcast — which serves approximately one million subscribers in the Chicago area — have been ongoing for months, according to sources. This situation has forced fans to consider switching to pay-TV services that have reached agreements, such as DirecTV, or purchasing a digital antenna to access the free, over-the-air high-definition signal.
“I’ve been holding out, hoping they will reach an agreement eventually,” Coleman noted. “Maybe as the Bulls get closer to starting their season, they’ll finally come to terms.”
“But if this continues for much longer, I’m not sure what I will do, which is really disappointing because I enjoy watching the games.”
The Blackhawks, Bulls, and White Sox have a new television home. Here’s what to know about the Chicago Sports Network.
Hang in there, Bailey; this could take some time.
One major obstacle at the heart of the deadlock appears to be a contentious issue. The cable provider disapproves of CHSN’s strategy to offer its sports programming for free to over-the-air viewers, according to informed sources.
Comcast is hesitant to finalize any deal with CHSN because it objects to paying for content that is available for free through over-the-air signals, sources have stated. As one industry insider remarked, “Here’s a free ice cream cone available, but you need to pay $5 for the one over here. I would definitely opt for the free cone.”
Approximately 15% of the 3.46 million households in the Chicago market utilize antennas for their TV viewing, as reported by Nielsen. An industry expert estimated that there are around 600,000 antenna users in the Chicago region, a figure that is significant enough to warrant attention from Comcast.
In an email sent on Friday, a Comcast representative confirmed that discussions with CHSN are ongoing but refrained from commenting on the specifics.
In the broader context, it’s crucial to note some of the key players involved.
Jerry Reinsdorf, chairman of the White Sox and Bulls, along with Danny Wirt…
In May, the Hawks’ chairman and CEO, z, collaborated with the Nashville-based Standard Media Group to establish CHSN.
Young Bulls fans wait for players before a preseason matchup against the Cavaliers on Oct. 18, 2024, at the United Center. (John J. Kim/Chicago Tribune)
Standard Media, which holds a 15% stake in CHSN, is part of Standard General, a hedge fund based in New York that also has control over the Bally’s casino chain, including its emerging flagship location in Chicago.
Bally’s name features prominently on a regional sports network owned by Sinclair, Diamond Sports Group, which is striving to recover from bankruptcy, reflecting the decline in the worth of programming that was once a lucrative asset for cable bundles.
“We are open to negotiations with all pay-TV providers, including Comcast,” remarked Soo Kim, founding partner of Standard General. “If you examine our history, any pay-TV provider that has shown a willingness to engage with us has successfully reached an agreement.”
In addition to his role at Standard General, Kim serves as chairman of Bally’s Corp., which commenced construction in August on a planned $1.7 billion Bally’s Chicago Casino, located on the site of the former Tribune Freedom Center printing plant along the Chicago River.
Sources acquainted with the teams’ negotiation strategies have observed that subscriptions to pay-TV services—both cable and streaming—are declining, compelling teams to devise innovative solutions to connect with fans by negotiating partnerships across various platforms.
Furthermore, they emphasize that CHSN’s over-the-air signal has, for the first time, made their games accessible to viewers using antennas, many of whom are unable to afford pay-TV services.
Column: Searching for the Blackhawks, Bulls, and White Sox on TV feels like a nostalgic journey back to the 1980s. Are they worth it?
<iframe loading="lazy" class="wp-embedded-content" sandbox="allow-scripts" security="restricted" style="position: absolute; visibility: hidden;" title="“Column: Searching for the Blackhawks, Bulls, and White Sox on TV is like a trip back to the 1980s
“Are they worth it?” — Chicago Tribune” src=”https://www.chicagotribune.com/2024/10/03/chsn-chicago-blackhawks-bulls-white-sox-tv/embed/#?secret=1R9ATMIRLq#?secret=NgKB4x3EWQ” data-secret=”NgKB4x3EWQ” width=”500″ height=”282″ frameborder=”0″ marginwidth=”0″ marginheight=”0″ scrolling=”no”>
Nevertheless, the significant revenues for regional sports networks like CHSN primarily stem from the carriage fees paid by Comcast and other pay-TV providers. This revenue is collected from pay-TV subscribers, regardless of whether they tune in to regional sports networks.
In the Chicago area, Comcast imposes a regional sports network fee of $19.20 per month. This fee appears as a specific line item on bills for the most well-liked cable subscription packages. The fee covers channels such as Marquee, NBC Sports Chicago, and the Big Ten Network.
Subscribers can expect to see a credit for the now-defunct NBC Sports Chicago on their upcoming bill, as indicated by the cable provider.
A representative speaking on behalf of the Bulls and White Sox mentioned that the Chicago teams are prepared to “take the hit” with a lower carriage fee than what was previously provided under NBC Sports Chicago. However, they believe it is unfair for fans to be expected to pay more while the teams absorb this financial hit. “That just doesn’t seem right,” they said.
Fans observe as Blackhawks center Connor Bedard walks the red carpet prior to the home opener against the Sharks on October 17, 2024, at the United Center. (Chris Sweda/Chicago Tribune)
So, what does this all mean for fans?
Industry insiders pointed to the situation in Pittsburgh.
In January, Comcast shifted SportsNet Pittsburgh, which broadcasts games for the Penguins and Pirates, from the standard TV tier to the more expensive “Ultimate TV” package, which costs about $20 more.
If Comcast decides to move CHSN to the Ultimate package in Chicago, the increase in monthly fees would only partly be counterbalanced by a decrease in the regional sports network fee, as Comcast continues to offer Marquee and the Big Ten Network.
“We appreciate SportsNet Pittsburgh collaborating with us to develop a solution that balances the cost and options available for consumers to enjoy local sports in this evolving video landscape,”
Comcast made a statement during that period, saying,
Clearly, if the teams believed they were facing a public relations challenge during the stalemate, it would be nothing in comparison to the backlash they would receive if the outcome resulted in increased cable bills.
“When you switch on your TV, it will show the Chicago Sports Network but will require you to pay more for a higher tier,” a source from the team explained. “Who’s going to bear the brunt of the blame? The teams will be the ones held accountable. However, it’s Comcast that is ultimately compelling viewers to upgrade to those higher tiers.”
Indeed, a significant amount of criticism on social media has already been directed at Reinsdorf, and to a lesser degree, Wirtz.
Danny Wirtz, chairman and CEO of the Blackhawks, responds to a question regarding “The 1901 Project” on October 2, 2024, at the Union League Club in the Loop. (Eileen T. Meslar/Chicago Tribune)
“I can relate to the fans,” Wirtz stated to the Tribune. “There’s nothing more frustrating than being unable to watch your favorite teams as you usually do. It’s wonderful that our fans are so passionate. … Therefore, I never fault anyone for feeling upset when such preferences are unable to be met, and it genuinely bothers me when we cannot provide that experience.
“Sadly, the television landscape in sports is undergoing a significant transformation, which we anticipated. We were aware from the outset of our previous agreement that we would be entering … almost an obstacle course of evolving dynamics in the media sector. …
“How do we ensure that games remain accessible alongside the business implications and the other parties involved in this scenario? There are many factors beyond our control. Although we view ourselves as a vital part of Chicago, we remain part of the broader strategies of larger national media companies, putting us in a challenging position. Unfortunately, through all of this, it is sometimes the fans who end up paying the price. Currently, they are struggling to access the games in the way they prefer.”
No definitive path has been established as of yet.
According to sources from the teams, the most recent official contract proposal was submitted on October 10, with no counteroffer from Comcast received thus far.
When questioned about the options available for CHSN, Stan Knott, the chief operating officer of Standard Media, refrained from commenting on the specific offers that have been made. “We have shown a commitment and remain committed to resolving this matter,” he stated.
Comcast, on the other hand, is known for lengthy negotiations and taking its time with teams.
For instance, Marquee Sports Network finalized a carriage agreement with Comcast four months after the Cubs’ channel launched, just in time for opening day, which had been postponed due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
In response to inquiries about the lack of urgency in finalizing a deal sooner, Wirtz remarked, “I don’t believe it’s a question of urgency. Rather, it reflects the nature of negotiations among these media companies. They typically do not conclude well in advance. Instead, agreements tend to be reached quite late in the process. Historically, that has been the pattern.”
Both parties have intensified their public pressure strategies.
We hear you… Now let @XfinitySupport hear you! pic.twitter.com/GzQJFovY2A
— Chicago Sports Network (@CHSN__) October 17, 2024
In the initial stages, the Hawks have been experiencing challenges. (The Bulls are set to begin their season on Wednesday.)
With Comcast’s extensive reach absent, Hawks’ ratings have dropped compared to last year, as per a source. Ticket sales at the United Center have also seen a slight decline.
The home opener against the San Jose Sharks attracted 19,056 fans, falling short of the 19,717 mark required for a sellout, which has historically been a source of pride for the franchise. Last season’s home opener recorded an attendance of 19,867.
Diverging from the financial approach of Danny’s grandfather, “Dollar” Bill Wirtz, who opted to keep games off television to fill seats, today’s matches serve as lengthy infomercials for the Hawks.
Coleman, a Hawks supporter, still attends some games with her father, Deron, but she is unable to go to every game and wishes to keep up with them on television. She mentioned that several friends are willing to hold out “because they don’t want to invest in an antenna, as it’s not the olden days.”
She has contemplated tuning into Hawks games on the WGN-AM 720 radio app because play-by-play announcer John Wiedeman is “pleasant to listen to.”
However, that option feels like “going even further back in time,” Coleman noted. “Yes, the radio.”
Tribune reporter Robert Channick contributed.
Originally Published: October 19, 2024 at 3:14 p.m.
Chicago Sports Network Standoff Leaves Blackhawks Fans in the Dark Amid Comcast Negotiations
The Ongoing Negotiations Between Comcast and Chicago Sports Network
Chicago sports enthusiasts, particularly Blackhawks fans, are currently facing uncertainty due to the ongoing negotiations between Comcast and the Chicago Sports Network (CSN). This standoff has significant implications for fans who rely on Comcast for their local sports coverage, especially during the NHL season.
Understanding the Negotiation Landscape
Comcast, as one of the major cable providers in the Chicago area, plays a crucial role in delivering sports content. CSN is a crucial network for fans looking to keep up with the Blackhawks and other local teams. Unfortunately, the failure to reach an agreement has led to a blackout of games for many viewers.
Key Reasons Behind the Standoff
- Dispute over Rights Fees: One of the primary reasons for the standoff is the disagreement over rights fees. CSN is seeking increased fees from Comcast, a move that the cable provider is hesitant to accept.
- Viewership Trends: With the rise of streaming services, traditional cable networks have seen a decline in viewership. This decline complicates negotiations as both parties reassess the value of local sports programming.
- Consumer Sentiment: Fans are increasingly vocal about their displeasure regarding pricing and access to games. This sentiment influences the negotiation dynamics.
The Impact on Blackhawks Fans
The ongoing negotiations have left many Blackhawks fans frustrated and in the dark. With the current standoff, fans are missing out on:
- Live Game Coverage: Without access to CSN, fans cannot watch live games, including critical matchups and rivalries.
- Pre- and Post-Game Shows: Fans are also missing out on essential analysis and discussions surrounding the games.
- Player Interviews and Insights: Coverage that provides deeper insights into player performances and team dynamics is no longer available.
Alternatives for Fans
While the negotiations continue, fans have a few alternatives to stay connected with the Blackhawks:
- Streaming Services: Several streaming platforms offer NHL coverage, such as NHL.tv and ESPN+. These may provide access to games that are unavailable on traditional cable.
- Social Media Updates: Following the Blackhawks on platforms like Twitter and Instagram can keep fans updated on scores, news, and highlights.
- Local Radio Broadcasts: Tune in to local radio stations that provide play-by-play commentary for Blackhawks games.
Benefits of Resolving the Negotiation Standoff
A successful resolution to the negotiations between Comcast and CSN would yield several benefits for fans and stakeholders alike:
- Accessible Game Coverage: Fans would regain access to all Blackhawks games, ensuring that they can cheer for their team in real-time.
- Enhanced Viewing Experience: With both parties motivated to improve viewer engagement, fans can expect better-quality broadcasts and additional content.
- Community Engagement: Local sports coverage fosters a sense of community and connection among fans, which is invaluable for the Chicago sports culture.
Case Study: Previous Negotiations and Their Outcomes
Examining past negotiations in sports broadcasting can provide insight into the current situation.
| Year | Network | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| 2019 | AT&T SportsNet | Agreement reached after prolonged negotiations, restoring coverage for fans. |
| 2020 | Bally Sports | Network launched with new streaming options, increasing fan accessibility. |
| 2021 | Fox Sports | Negotiations led to improved programming, including behind-the-scenes content. |
First-Hand Experience: A Blackhawks Fan’s Perspective
Many Blackhawks fans have shared their experiences during this standoff, highlighting the challenges they face. One fan, Sarah J., expressed her frustration:
“I’ve been a Blackhawks fan my entire life, and not being able to watch the games feels like a part of me is missing. I hope they resolve this soon!”
This sentiment resonates among many fans who are eager for a resolution that allows them to support their team fully.
Looking Ahead: What Fans Can Expect
While the outcome of the negotiations remains to be seen, fans can keep an eye on the following:
- Updates from Both Parties: Regular updates from Comcast and CSN can provide clarity on the progress of negotiations.
- Fan Initiatives: Engaging in fan initiatives or campaigns can help amplify the concerns and desires of the Blackhawks fan community.
- Exploring Other Options: Fans should remain informed about alternative viewing options to tide them over during this uncertain period.
Conclusion
As Chicago Blackhawks fans find themselves in the dark amid the Comcast and Chicago Sports Network standoff, the situation underscores the importance of accessible sports broadcasting. With ongoing negotiations, fans are hopeful for a swift resolution that brings back their beloved games to their screens.
