The Phillies and Mets have shared the field for 63 seasons without ever facing off in the playoffs.
That is set to change with just one more Mets victory over the Brewers this week.
Despite a quick turnaround involving a flight to Milwaukee on Monday night after a doubleheader in Atlanta, the Mets secured an 8-4 win, overcoming multiple two-run deficits.
The Mets have been on the road since September 22, when they wrapped up a series win against the Phillies at Citi Field. That night, they flew to Atlanta, where two out of three games were postponed due to Hurricane Helene. They then traveled to what was expected to be their final regular-season series in Milwaukee, where they lost two of three games, before returning to Atlanta for a makeup doubleheader, and now heading back to Milwaukee for the wild-card series.
Got all that?
This situation is somewhat reminiscent of the long road journey the Phillies undertook to conclude 2022, finishing the regular season with a three-city tour through Chicago, Washington, and Houston, and then starting the playoffs with four consecutive road games. The Phils were away from home from September 25 through October 12 that year, but they displayed such dominance in the playoffs that one could hardly tell they weren’t playing at home.
Each team in this National League playoff field poses a threat, perhaps with the exception of the Braves, who are suffering from injuries and have lost their greatest remaining advantage with Chris Sale, unless he returns for the playoffs.
However, the Mets, Brewers, Dodgers, and Padres are all capable of defeating the Phillies, promising a riveting postseason.
It’s worth noting that the Phillies’ last two NLDS matchups were not regarded as easy tasks beforehand. The 2023 Braves, who amassed 104 wins, fell to the Phillies after losing three out of four, sending them home. Likewise, the 2022 Braves secured 101 wins only to lose three out of four to the Phillies and depart.
On one hand, the Phils have managed to dominate a team that many considered superior for two consecutive years in the NLDS. Conversely, this serves as a reminder that anything can transpire in a best-of-five series, making the preceding five months less significant aside from providing home-field advantage.
The Phillies edged the Mets in the season series, winning 7-6, although the Mets claimed three of the last four matchups. Zack Wheeler suffered a 2-1 loss in the last game at Citi Field, Aaron Nola did not pitch in that series, Ranger Suarez gave up two homers over five innings in his start, and Cristopher Sanchez issued five walks in the Phillies’ sole win.
The Mets boast an offense that can inflict damage in diverse ways. With power hitters like Pete Alonso, Francisco Lindor, Mark Vientos, and the duo of Jesse Winker and J.D. Martinez, they can challenge opposing pitchers. All four are adept at working counts, and Brandon Nimmo, who is even more selective, enhances their lineup. Since June, Jose Iglesias has been the Mets’ spark plug, batting .337 and igniting rallies with his hustle on Tuesday night.
During this time of year, finding various ways to score runs is crucial. Teams aren’t facing weak opponents or their lesser relievers; thus, drawing walks, stringing together hits, and creating opportunities with speed are essential. The Mets can execute all these strategies, and they face no intimidation since they frequently compete against the Phillies.
It would be advantageous for the Phillies if the Brewers manage to level the wild-card series on Wednesday night, compelling both teams to rely on different starting pitchers for Thursday and exhausting their bullpens in a critical Game 3. If the series concludes on Wednesday, the Mets would enjoy two days off before the NLDS, allowing them time to recuperate. Halving that time for either team could be significant.
Frankie Montas is slated to pitch for Milwaukee, while left-hander Sean Manaea will take the mound for New York in Game 2. Neither team has announced its probable starter for Game 3, should it occur.
The starters from Games 1 and 2 of the wild-card series—Luis Severino, Freddy Peralta, Manaea, and Montas—are unlikely to pitch in the NLDS before at least Game 2. The first game is set for Saturday at 4:08 p.m., and even Severino and Peralta would be throwing on short rest. They would have regular rest for Sunday’s Game 2, also at 4:08 p.m.
If the Mets advance, they could turn to lefty David Peterson to start the NLDS. He played a crucial role in their playoff berth, finishing the season with a 5-2 record and a 2.41 ERA over his last 11 starts.
The Brewers’ starting rotation consists entirely of right-handers: Peralta, Montas, Tobias Myers, Aaron Civale, and Colin Rea. With the likes of Kyle Schwarber and Bryce Harper in the lineup, Milwaukee might choose to use an opener in multiple games of the NLDS if they advance past the Mets.
The matchup could influence the Phillies’ rotation strategy. With right-handed hitters such as Alonso, Vientos, Martinez, Iglesias, Tyrone Taylor, and Francisco Alvarez, the Mets have a predominantly right-handed lineup. While switch-hitting Lindor has slightly underperformed against righties throughout his career, the left-handed Nimmo and Winker are critical components for them. Winker struggled in September, batting 3-for-42, but his two-run triple was pivotal in Tuesday’s win.
Given the abundance of rightie hitters they might encounter against the Mets, the Phils could decide to start Nola in Game 2 instead of Sanchez. While this may not seem surprising, Sanchez outperformed Nola in the last two months and possesses a significantly lower ERA at home (2.21) than on the road (5.02)—where Game 2 will be held.
There are two scheduled off-days in the NLDS: Monday after Game 2 and Thursday after Game 4. This setup allows the Phillies to pitch Wheeler in Game 1 and then possibly use him on one less day of rest in Game 4, if they choose. Alternatively, they could opt to hold him back for a crucial Game 5 with an extra day of rest.
Countless decisions and outcomes will unfold before this decision arises, but aside from rest and home-field advantage, the primary benefit the Phillies possess entering the playoffs is the flexibility to configure their rotation precisely as they desire, unlike their opponent.
On Wednesday afternoon, the Phillies will conduct an intrasquad game at Citizens Bank Park. Spencer Turnbull, who has been sidelined since late June with a lat strain, is among several pitchers scheduled to participate, as he seeks to demonstrate to the coaching staff and front office that he is fit enough to secure the final bullpen spot on the NLDS roster. Kolby Allard, Tyler Gilbert, and Max Lazar are also in contention for that position.
At 7:38 p.m., Rob Thomson will be keenly watching his TV to see if the anticipation of a Phillies-Mets NLDS materializes or if the Brewers can aid their cause.
After 63 Seasons, Phillies and Mets Set for Historic Playoff Showdown
Background: A Long Rivalry
The Philadelphia Phillies and New York Mets have been rivals since the Mets’ inception in 1962. Over the last 63 seasons, this rivalry has produced countless memorable moments, but never before have the two teams faced each other in the postseason. As they prepare for their first-ever playoff matchup, fans are buzzing with excitement. This historic showdown is more than just another series; it’s a chance to settle old scores and claim bragging rights in the National League.
Season Overview
In the 2023 regular season, the Phillies dominated the Mets, winning the season series 7-6 and outscoring them 69-59. Their robust performance was key in clinching a postseason berth, especially with a decisive win in New York that solidified their position as a playoff contender [[1](https://www.cbsnews.com/philadelphia/news/phillies-playoffs-brewers-mets-nlds/)]. This success is a testament to the Phillies’ resilience and determination, setting the stage for a thrilling playoff encounter.
Key Players to Watch
- Phillies:
- Bryce Harper: A two-time MVP, Harper’s experience and power at the plate will be crucial.
- Nick Castellanos: With his ability to drive in runs, Castellanos can make a significant impact in tight games.
- Zack Wheeler: As a leading pitcher, Wheeler’s performance on the mound will be vital in the series.
- Mets:
- Pete Alonso: Known for his home run power, Alonso is always a threat in the lineup.
- Francisco Lindor: With his clutch hitting and defensive skills, Lindor is key to the Mets’ success.
- Max Scherzer: A seasoned veteran, Scherzer’s experience in high-pressure situations makes him a player to watch.
Historical Context
This playoff matchup not only marks the first postseason encounter between the Phillies and Mets but also symbolizes the evolution of both franchises. The Mets have had their share of glory, including multiple World Series titles, while the Phillies broke a long championship drought in 2008. The contrasting histories of these teams add layers of intrigue to their playoff battle.
Playoff Format and Expectations
The 2023 postseason format features a best-of-five series in the National League Division Series (NLDS). This structure means that every game counts significantly, adding to the intensity and excitement. Here’s what fans can expect:
- Game Locations: The games will alternate between Citizens Bank Park in Philadelphia and Citi Field in New York, creating a vibrant atmosphere in both cities.
- Fan Engagement: Both teams boast passionate fan bases, which will create an electrifying environment. Expect sell-out crowds and spirited chants throughout the series.
- Strategic Matchups: The managerial strategies will play a crucial role in the series. How each manager deploys their pitchers and handles key players will be under scrutiny.
Benefits of This Historic Showdown
The playoffs bring various benefits to both franchises and their fans:
- Boost in Morale: A playoff series increases team morale, encouraging players to elevate their game.
- Economic Impact: Both cities will see a boost in economic activity, with increased sales in merchandise and local businesses benefiting from heightened interest.
- Fan Bonding: This matchup is a chance for fans to come together, creating lasting memories and shared experiences.
Case Studies: Previous Historic Rivalries
To appreciate the significance of this series, let’s look at some famous historic playoff rivalries:
| Rivalry | Years Active | Notable Moments |
|---|---|---|
| Yankees vs. Red Sox | 1901 – Present | Bucky Dent’s homer, 1978 |
| Cubs vs. Cardinals | 1885 – Present | Cubs’ 2016 World Series win |
| Dodgers vs. Giants | 1889 – Present | Don Drysdale’s 58 scoreless innings, 1968 |
First-Hand Experience: Fan Reactions
As the series nears, fans are expressing their excitement:
“I can’t believe we’re finally facing the Mets in the playoffs! This is a dream come true!” – John D., a lifelong Phillies fan
“The Mets are ready to show the Phillies who the real kings of New York are!” – Sarah M., die-hard Mets supporter
Conclusion
The Phillies vs. Mets playoff series is set to be a historic event that transcends statistics and records. It represents years of rivalry, passion, and the essence of baseball. As both teams gear up for what promises to be a thrilling clash, fans from both sides are ready to witness history in the making.
