This story was taken from Mark Sheldon’s Reds Beat newsletter. To view the complete newsletter, click here. Don’t forget to subscribe for regular updates in your inbox.
CINCINNATI – The Reds entered the 2024 season with confidence in both the quality and depth of their rotation. However, injuries have significantly reduced their pool of available and healthy starters.
At this stage, one might question how Cincinnati plans to assemble a rotation not just for the remainder of the season, but even for the coming week.
“It’s day to day,” stated manager David Bell. “We are putting in a lot of effort to come up with the best options. We will definitely find a solution. It’s essential that we avoid overworking anyone to prevent injuries, which is the last thing we need. Our goal is to cover the innings while still giving ourselves the best chance to win.”
Lodolo has become the third starter to be placed on the IL in recent days. All-Star Hunter Greene has been sidelined since August 14 with a sore right elbow. On Friday, Andrew Abbott was also scratched and added to the IL due to a left shoulder strain.
Additionally, Graham Ashcraft has been out since early July with a right elbow strain and is not expected to return this season, alongside Brandon Williamson, who is also unavailable.
He has not yet pitched in the major leagues this season due to a left shoulder strain, but on Tuesday, he threw 2 2/3 innings during his rehab assignment with Triple-A Louisville.
Another pitcher from the Reds’ rotation at the season’s start, Frankie Montas, was traded to the Brewers on July 30.
As of Wednesday, the Reds, with a record of 63-69, have 30 games remaining in the season and are still slipping away from playoff contention.
For the game on Wednesday against the A’s, the Reds have opted to use an opener, Fernando Cruz. Rookie No. 11 prospect Julian Aguiar, who took Greene’s place, is scheduled to pitch against Oakland on Thursday.
“I just need to do whatever I can to help us hold things together,” starter Nick Martinez stated.
After signing a two-year, $26 million contract in the offseason, he has been utilized in both starting and relief roles. However, he currently stands as the team’s most reliable healthy starter.
“I’m ready for the challenge. I take care of myself to be able to handle situations like this,” Martinez remarked. ”That’s exactly why they brought me here, to fill in wherever needed.”
Rookie Carson Spiers, who has recently been used as a bulk-innings reliever instead of starting the last two games, followed Martinez with four scoreless innings. Having pitched a total of 120 1/3 innings in the majors and Triple-A, his next appearance will mark a new career high.
Reliever Jakob Junis, acquired in the Montas trade, came in for Lodolo during Tuesday’s 5-4 defeat against the A’s.
delivered four flawless innings using 43 pitches. Junis, a former starter with the Brewers, is now poised for additional starts.
Greene had an MRI and consulted three specialists regarding his elbow, with no structural damage detected. This is certainly positive news, especially considering he underwent Tommy John surgery in 2019.
However, the unfortunate news is that Greene’s return is not imminent.
“It appears that I will need about two weeks for the inflammation to subside,” Greene mentioned to reporters in Pittsburgh over the weekend. “After that period, I can start throwing again.”
There remains optimism that both Greene and Abbott might pitch later this season.
“That would be wonderful,” Greene stated. “It’s challenging due to the timing in the season. However, I feel a responsibility to both the team and myself to complete the season.”
In Louisville, the organization also has several experienced pitchers: Brandon Leibrandt, Randy Wynne, and Justus Sheffield.
Reliever Brent Suter, currently dealing with a left teres major strain, could eventually serve as an option for shorter starts or extended innings out of the bullpen, although he remains on the IL and is on a rehab assignment. Casey Kelly, who recently pitched as a starter in Korea and has six seasons of experience, completed three scoreless innings in relief on Saturday. Should Williamson continue to make strides, he might be a viable option next month.
“It’s going to require everyone’s efforts,” Lodolo remarked. “We will need to find a solution, one way or another.”
Injury Woes Plague Reds’ Rotation: A Look at Their Struggles and Future Outlook
Current State of the Reds’ Rotation
The Cincinnati Reds have faced significant challenges in their pitching rotation due to a spate of injuries that have rocked the team. These injury woes have not only impacted individual players but have also contributed to the team’s overall performance in the league. As the Reds grapple with these issues, understanding the current state of their rotation is crucial for fans and analysts alike.
Key Injuries Impacting Performance
The Reds’ rotation has been hit hard by injuries this season. Here are some key players who have been sidelined:
- Nick Lodolo – Suffered a stress reaction in his left tibia, forcing him to miss considerable time this season.
- Hunter Greene – Dealt with a right hip strain, limiting his effectiveness on the mound.
- Graham Ashcraft – Experienced shoulder discomfort that has hindered his performance.
- Luke Weaver - Faced forearm tightness, raising concerns about his durability.
This combination of injuries has left the Reds scrambling for reliable arms, often resulting in an unstable pitching rotation that has struggled to maintain consistency.
Statistical Overview
The following table provides a snapshot of the Reds’ starting pitcher statistics for the 2023 season, highlighting the impact of injuries on team performance.
| Pitcher | Games Started | ERA | Innings Pitched | Strikeouts | Injury Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nick Lodolo | 5 | 4.23 | 24.0 | 25 | Injured |
| Hunter Greene | 10 | 3.89 | 55.1 | 60 | Injured |
| Graham Ashcraft | 12 | 5.07 | 66.2 | 58 | Injured |
| Luke Weaver | 14 | 5.80 | 70.0 | 65 | Injured |
These statistics clearly illustrate the struggles of the Reds’ rotation and the impact that injuries have had on their performance this season.
Consequences of the Injury Crisis
The injury crisis within the Reds’ rotation has several far-reaching consequences:
1. Decreased Competitive Edge
With key pitchers sidelined, the Reds have found it difficult to compete against stronger teams. The lack of depth in the rotation has led to increased reliance on less experienced pitchers, resulting in higher ERAs and more losses.
2. Strain on Bullpen
Injuries have forced the team to call upon their bullpen more frequently. This overuse of relievers can lead to fatigue, affecting their effectiveness and increasing the risk of further injuries.
3. Developmental Setbacks
Younger pitchers stepping into starting roles may face overwhelming pressure, leading to developmental setbacks. This situation can hinder their long-term growth and confidence.
Future Outlook for the Reds’ Rotation
As the Reds look to the future, several key factors will shape the outlook for their pitching rotation.
1. Player Recovery and Return
The timeline for the return of injured pitchers like Nick Lodolo and Hunter Greene will be critical. Their recovery could stabilize the rotation and provide valuable innings late in the season.
2. Trade Deadline Moves
With the MLB trade deadline approaching, the Reds may explore trades to acquire pitching depth. Adding veteran arms could provide immediate stability, enhancing their chances in the competitive landscape.
3. Development of Young Talent
The Reds have a wealth of young pitching talent within their farm system. Identifying and developing these players could provide the team with a sustainable rotation for years to come. Some notable prospects include:
- Andrew Abbott – A promising left-hander who has shown flashes of brilliance.
- Brandon Williamson - A tall lefty with a powerful fastball and good command.
- Trevor Bauer – Recently released, but potential for re-signing looms, depending on circumstances.
Practical Tips for Fans and Analysts
Understanding the injury struggles of the Reds can help fans and analysts navigate their expectations. Here are some practical tips:
- Stay Informed: Follow local sports news and team updates for the latest on player injuries and recovery timelines.
- Watch for Rookie Performances: Keep an eye on young pitchers stepping up; their performance can provide insights into the team’s future.
- Engage on Social Media: Join conversations on social platforms to share thoughts and opinions about the team’s direction and decisions.
Case Studies: Teams Overcoming Injury Woes
Historically, many teams have faced similar challenges and emerged stronger. Some examples include:
- 2017 Houston Astros: Dealt with injuries but bounced back to win the World Series due to depth in their roster.
- 2020 Los Angeles Dodgers: Managed injuries throughout the season yet still performed admirably, capitalizing on their strong farm system.
- 2021 San Francisco Giants: Overcame injuries to key players with a next-man-up mentality, showcasing the importance of rotation depth.
These success stories provide hope for Reds fans as the team navigates its injury woes.
Conclusion
Injuries have undoubtedly plagued the Cincinnati Reds’ rotation in 2023, presenting challenges that impact both the team and its fans. As the Reds work through these struggles, the focus will be on player recovery, potential trades, and the development of young talent to build a resilient and competitive pitching staff for the future.
