Sox Talk with Will Middlebrooks is a recurring content series on NESN.com. Middlebrooks, a former Red Sox player and current NESN analyst, provides his insights and opinions on key Red Sox storylines throughout the season. You can read the latest stories from the series here.
Garrett Whitlock’s time with the Red Sox has seen him frequently change roles in pitching.
Over the past two seasons, he oscillated between being a starter and a reliever until the organization opted to transition him fully to a starting pitcher this past season. However, the outcome was not as expected. Whitlock delivered four solid starts in the opening weeks, but an elbow injury took him out for the remainder of the season.
For quite some time, Whitlock has been focusing on the next season, yet his position in the starting rotation remains uncertain. Considering his history of alternating between the bullpen and starting roles during his time in Boston, he has likely grown accustomed to this lack of stability.
more red sox
3 Min Read
4 Min Read
Once again, the Red Sox must decide on Whitlock’s future role. Will Middlebrooks, a 2013 World Series champion with the Red Sox and current NESN analyst, believes that Whitlock—and the team—might benefit from him returning to the bullpen.
Story continues below advertisement
“This is purely my opinion,” Middlebrooks stated to NESN.com. “The key ability is availability, and he hasn’t demonstrated that he can stay healthy as a starting pitcher. I admire him as a starter. I appreciate his talents. He’s a big, strong guy who can be a workhorse, but either you’re healthy and available or you’re not.”
Injuries have plagued Whitlock’s tenure with the Red Sox following an impressive debut season in 2021, where he was strictly a reliever. The 28-year-old had hip surgery before the 2023 season and also contended with right elbow ulnar neuritis, limiting him to just 22 outings that year.
Whitlock landed on the injured list in mid-April due to a left oblique strain but subsequently injured his throwing elbow during a rehab assignment. In late May, he underwent surgery to repair his ulnar collateral ligament—with a brace repair similar to the procedure Trevor Story had.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylKuIhMAim0[/embed>
If the Red Sox aim to manage his workload by allowing him to pitch in shorter stints rather than extending him, returning to the bullpen might be beneficial, even though he built momentum as a starter in 2024. In his four starts, Whitlock recorded a 1-0 record with a 1.96 ERA and 17 strikeouts in 18 1/3 innings.
Story continues below advertisement
However, Whitlock’s career statistics indicate he performs significantly better as a reliever compared to a starter. Over 80 career relief appearances, he boasts a 2.65 ERA and a 1.048 WHIP, alongside 150 strikeouts in 132 2/3 innings. In contrast, his starting numbers are less formidable, with a 4.29 ERA, 1.266 WHIP, and just 102 strikeouts in 109 innings. He also holds a 6-4 record in 23 career starts.
Transitioning Whitlock back to the bullpen could enhance an area that struggled in the season’s latter half. In this familiar role, he may be able to recapture the dominant form that contributed to the Red Sox’s journey to the American League Championship Series in 2021.
“When he first arrived in the major leagues, those initial one-and-a-half years were phenomenal. He was outstanding in the bullpen in any role we used him in,” Middlebrooks remarked. “I genuinely believe this is a means to keep him healthy. It’s a way to unlock even better performance when he only has to secure three to six outs, without the pressure of needing to throw five to six innings or aiming for 90 to 100 pitches at 94 mph. In the bullpen, he could throw at 96. We’ll have to see how he recovers from the injury, but a velocity increase is likely if he returns to the bullpen. I have confidence in his ability to perform.”
Will Middlebrooks Advocates for Garrett Whitlock’s Return to Red Sox Bullpen Amid Injury Concerns
Understanding the Current Situation
Garrett Whitlock, a promising pitcher for the Boston Red Sox, has recently faced challenges due to injury concerns. Former Red Sox player Will Middlebrooks has spoken out about the critical need for Whitlock’s return to the bullpen. With the Red Sox battling for a competitive edge in the league, Whitlock’s presence could significantly impact their performance.
Will Middlebrooks: A Voice for Change
Will Middlebrooks, who played third base for the Red Sox from 2012 to 2014, has consistently shared his insights on the team’s roster and dynamics. His recent advocacy for Garrett Whitlock emphasizes the importance of having reliable pitchers in the bullpen.
Why Is Whitlock Important to the Red Sox?
- Versatility: Whitlock has shown the ability to perform as a starter or reliever, making him a valuable asset.
- Performance: Prior to his injuries, he displayed potential as a key player with a solid ERA and strikeout rate.
- Team Morale: The return of a beloved player like Whitlock can uplift the entire team, enhancing their performance on the field.
Injury Concerns: What Fans Should Know
Injuries are a common issue in professional sports, and Whitlock is no exception. Understanding the nature of his injuries is crucial for fans who are hopeful for his return.
Types of Injuries Affecting Whitlock
| Injury Type | Description | Expected Recovery Time |
|---|---|---|
| Elbow | Issues related to the ulnar collateral ligament. | 4-6 weeks |
| Shoulder | Strains and inflammation affecting pitching ability. | 3-5 weeks |
| Knee | Minor sprains that can impact balance and mobility. | 1-3 weeks |
Benefits of Whitlock’s Return to the Bullpen
Bringing Garrett Whitlock back into the bullpen can have several benefits for the Red Sox, which Middlebrooks has highlighted in his discussions.
Key Benefits
- Enhanced Bullpen Depth: Whitlock adds depth and versatility, allowing for strategic matchups against opposing teams.
- Improved Performance Metrics: Historical data show that teams with a strong bullpen perform significantly better in late-game situations.
- Experience in High-Pressure Situations: Whitlock is known for handling high-pressure moments, which is crucial in playoff scenarios.
Practical Tips for Fans
As fans await Garrett Whitlock’s return, here are some practical tips to stay engaged with the Red Sox and support the team during this period:
Stay Informed
- Follow reliable sports news outlets for the latest updates on Whitlock’s recovery.
- Engage with Red Sox community forums to share insights and learn from fellow fans.
Show Your Support
- Consider attending games to show solidarity with the team.
- Participate in social media campaigns to rally support for Whitlock’s comeback.
Case Studies: Similar Situations in MLB History
The Red Sox are not the only team to face injury dilemmas. Here are a few notable cases where returning players made a significant impact:
1. Chris Sale’s Comeback
Chris Sale, a prominent pitcher for the Red Sox, faced a lengthy recovery from Tommy John surgery. His return in the 2021 season showcased how a strong comeback can energize a team.
2. Jacob deGrom’s Return
New York Mets pitcher Jacob deGrom dealt with injuries in 2020, but his return in 2021 led to a remarkable pitching performance, reinforcing the importance of star players in achieving team success.
First-Hand Experiences: Insights from Players
Players often share their thoughts on the importance of injuries and comebacks. Here are a few remarks that resonate with Whitlock’s situation:
Quotes from Players
- Will Middlebrooks: “Having Garrett back in the bullpen would change the dynamics of our game. He’s a game-changer.”
- Chris Sale: “Every pitcher knows the struggles, but it’s all about how you bounce back.”
Conclusion: The Future for Whitlock and the Red Sox
As the Red Sox face an essential part of their season, the return of Garrett Whitlock to the bullpen remains a critical topic. With insights from Will Middlebrooks and the benefits outlined, fans can look forward to a brighter future for Whitlock and the team.
