Is Aaron Judge MLB’s Top Player Right Now? Expert Debate Heats Up
There’s little doubt that Shohei Ohtani will be crowned the top player in Major League Baseball soon. However, the question of who comes in second is sparking passionate debate among experts.in a poll of 14 MLB.com insiders, the top spot was a close call between New York Yankees slugger Aaron Judge and Kansas City Royals phenom Bobby Witt Jr.
Judge ultimately edged out Witt, securing 92 points compared to Witt’s 87. Two additional first-place votes for Judge proved the difference. This fierce competition highlights the extraordinary talent currently gracing the MLB diamond.
Judge’s recent dominance is undeniable. He has won the American League MVP Award twice in the last three seasons,leading the league in home runs,RBIs,on-base percentage,slugging percentage,and WAR. His 2024 season saw him shatter the record for OPS+ by a right-handed hitter,surpassing Rogers Hornsby’s century-old mark.
Despite Judge’s offensive prowess, some experts believe Witt’s all-around abilities give him the edge for the long term. Witt possesses remarkable speed,strong defense,and a growing offensive arsenal. However, for the immediate future, Judge’s consistent offensive production appears to be the deciding factor.
“Judge is not the baserunner and defender that Witt Jr. is, and he’s also eight years older.Those things matter,” acknowledged director of stats and research Mike Petriello.
“But for the moment, he did just put up two of the three best hitting seasons by a right-handed hitter in baseball history, and a move back to right field ought to take some of the stress off his defense. If we’re talking the next two, three or five years, I’m problably saying Witt.For just 2025? I’ll ride with Judge again.”
Bobby Witt Jr.: The MLB’s Evolving No. 1 Player
Kansas City Royals shortstop Bobby Witt Jr. is gaining serious traction as the top player in Major League Baseball, surpassing established stars like Aaron Judge. The 22-year-old emerged as one of the league’s most dynamic players in 2023, fueling the Royals’ return to the postseason.
several experts, when asked about the top player in the league, picked Witt over Judge despite the veteran’s second MVP season. Witt’s combination of elite hitting, exceptional defense, and rare athleticism secured him a place in the top tier of baseball players.
His outstanding 2023 campaign saw him rank among the best in MLB in batting run value, baserunning, and fielding run value. This, coupled with his youthful potential and room for growth, convinces many that Witt is poised for even greater heights.
Witt’s impact on the Royals was undeniable. His performance helped the team significantly improve their record and secure their first playoff appearance in nine years.
Beyond Witt: Other Top Contenders
While witt is stealing the spotlight, other players like Juan Soto, Mookie Betts, and Julio Rodríguez continue to shine.
Soto’s incredible offensive prowess, acknowledged by his recent $765 million contract with the Mets, makes him a force to be reckoned with.
Betts, a decade-long powerhouse, continues to showcase his versatility and elite talent. Rodríguez, simultaneously occurring, is a budding star with immense potential.
The race for the No. 1 player title is heating up, promising a thrilling season of exceptional play and fierce competition.