MLB Commissioner Clarifies Policy on Permanently Ineligible Players After Death
Major League Baseball Commissioner Robert D. Manfred Jr. has issued a landmark decision regarding the status of individuals who die while on MLB’s permanently ineligible list. The ruling, prompted by a request from Pete Rose‘s family, clarifies that permanent ineligibility ends upon the death of the individual.
The Commissioner’s Rationale
In a letter to Rose’s attorney, Jeffrey M.Lenkov, Commissioner Manfred explained his reasoning. He stated that the purposes behind Rule 21,which governs ineligibility,are to protect the integrity of the game and deter future misconduct. Manfred argued that once an individual has passed away, they no longer pose a threat to the game’s integrity, and the lifetime ban already serves as the ultimate deterrent.
“In my opinion,once a person has passed away,the purposes of Rule 21 have been fulfilled,” Manfred wrote. “Obviously, a person who is no longer with us cannot pose a threat to the integrity of the game. In addition, it is challenging to conceive of a sanction that has a greater deterrent affect than one that lasts a lifetime, without pardon. Therefore, I have concluded that permanent ineligibility ends with the passing of the disciplined person, and Mr. Rose will be removed from the list of permanent ineligibles.”
Consistency with Past Expectations?
Manfred further clarified that his decision aligns with the expectations of Commissioner Giamatti at the time of rose’s initial ineligibility. Rose’s placement on the ineligible list stemmed from a 1989 agreement to avoid potential litigation, rather than a direct ruling by the Commissioner.
Manfred noted that Giamatti’s comments were reasonable, considering the Hall of Fame at that time lacked a rule prohibiting the consideration of permanently ineligible individuals.he pointed out that “Shoeless” Joe Jackson, despite his ban, received Hall of Fame votes in both 1936 and 1946.
MLB Reinstates Deceased Players on Ineligible list, Opening Hall of Fame Possibilities
Major League Baseball has reversed its long-standing policy, reinstating deceased players previously on the permanently ineligible list. This decision opens the door for Hall of Fame consideration for figures tainted by scandal, including members of the infamous “Black Sox” team.
Hall of Fame Eligibility Restored
The Baseball Hall of Fame confirmed that individuals removed from the ineligible list are now eligible for Hall of Fame consideration. Jane Forbes Clark, chairman of the Hall of Fame’s board, stated that the Past Overview Committee will create an eight-name ballot for candidates whose greatest impact on the game occurred before 1980.The Classic Baseball Era Committee will vote on this ballot in December 2027.
Affected Players: The Black Sox and More
The MLB’s decision impacts 17 deceased individuals, including eight members of the 1919 Chicago White Sox team, known as the “Black Sox,” who were banned for fixing the World Series. Key figures include Eddie Cicotte,Happy Felsch,Chick Gandil,Joe Jackson,Fred McMullin,Swede Risberg,Buck Weaver,and Lefty Williams,along with Joe Gedeon,Gene Paulette,Benny Kauff,Lee Magee,Phil Douglas,Cozy Dolan,Jimmy O’Connell,and William Cox.
Pete Rose Situation Addressed
While the MLB’s declaration included Pete Rose, who is still alive, the change in policy will be applied to individuals, in the past or future, who are posthumously on the permanently ineligible list.
Reds’ Ownership expresses Gratitude
Bob castellini, owner of the Cincinnati Reds, voiced his appreciation for Commissioner Manfred’s decision regarding Pete Rose. “Pete is one of the greatest players in baseball history, and the Red’s Nation will continue to celebrate him as we always have.”
How might this policy change (ending permanent ineligibility upon death) affect the *audience’s* perception of the Hall of fame and the integrity of baseball history?
MLB Commissioner Clarifies Policy on Permanently Ineligible Players After Death
Major League Baseball Commissioner Robert D. Manfred Jr. has issued a landmark decision regarding the status of individuals who die while on MLB’s permanently ineligible list. The ruling, prompted by a request from Pete Rose’s family,clarifies that permanent ineligibility ends upon the death of the individual.
The Commissioner’s Rationale
in a letter to Rose’s attorney, Jeffrey M.Lenkov, commissioner Manfred explained his reasoning. He stated that the purposes behind Rule 21,which governs ineligibility,are to protect the integrity of the game and deter future misconduct. Manfred argued that once an individual has passed away, they no longer pose a threat to the game’s integrity, and the lifetime ban already serves as the ultimate deterrent.
“In my opinion,once a person has passed away,the purposes of Rule 21 have been fulfilled,” Manfred wrote. “Obviously, a person who is no longer with us cannot pose a threat to the integrity of the game. In addition, it is challenging to conceive of a sanction that has a greater deterrent affect than one that lasts a lifetime, without pardon. therefore, I have concluded that permanent ineligibility ends with the passing of the disciplined person, and Mr. rose will be removed from the list of permanent ineligibles.”
Consistency with Past Expectations?
Manfred further clarified that his decision aligns with the expectations of Commissioner Giamatti at the time of rose’s initial ineligibility. Rose’s placement on the ineligible list stemmed from a 1989 agreement to avoid potential litigation, rather than a direct ruling by the Commissioner.
Manfred noted that Giamatti’s comments were reasonable, considering the Hall of Fame at that time lacked a rule prohibiting the consideration of permanently ineligible individuals.he pointed out that “Shoeless” Joe Jackson, despite his ban, received Hall of Fame votes in both 1936 and 1946.
MLB Reinstates Deceased Players on Ineligible list, Opening Hall of Fame Possibilities
Major League Baseball has reversed it’s long-standing policy, reinstating deceased players previously on the permanently ineligible list. This decision opens the door for Hall of Fame consideration for figures tainted by scandal, including members of the infamous “Black Sox” team.
Hall of Fame Eligibility Restored
The baseball Hall of Fame confirmed that individuals removed from the ineligible list are now eligible for Hall of Fame consideration. Jane Forbes Clark, chairman of the Hall of Fame’s board, stated that the Past Overview Commitee will create an eight-name ballot for candidates whose greatest impact on the game occurred before 1980.The Classic Baseball Era Committee will vote on this ballot in December 2027.
Affected Players: The black Sox and More
The MLB’s decision impacts 17 deceased individuals, including eight members of the 1919 Chicago White sox team, known as the “Black Sox,” who were banned for fixing the World Series. Key figures include Eddie Cicotte,Happy Felsch,Chick Gandil,Joe Jackson,Fred McMullin,Swede Risberg,Buck Weaver,and Lefty williams,along with Joe Gedeon,Gene Paulette,Benny Kauff,lee Magee,Phil Douglas,Cozy Dolan,Jimmy O’Connell,and William Cox.
Pete Rose Situation Addressed
While the MLB’s declaration included Pete Rose, who is still alive, the change in policy will be applied to individuals, in the past or future, who are posthumously on the permanently ineligible list.
Reds’ Ownership expresses Gratitude
Bob castellini, owner of the Cincinnati Reds, voiced his appreciation for Commissioner Manfred’s decision regarding Pete Rose. “Pete is one of the greatest players in baseball history,and the Red’s Nation will continue to celebrate him as we always have.”
Q&A: MLB’s New Policy on Ineligible Players
What exactly has changed regarding permanently ineligible players?
MLB has decided that permanent ineligibility ends upon the death of the player. This means players previously banned for life, like those involved in the Black Sox Scandal, can now be considered for the Baseball Hall of fame.
why did MLB make this change?
Commissioner Manfred stated that the purpose of Rule 21 (governing ineligibility) is to protect the game’s integrity and deter misconduct.He believes that once a person is deceased, they no longer pose a threat, and the lifetime ban has already served its purpose. the change was partly prompted by a request from Pete Rose’s family.
Who does this affect?
This affects any player who was on the permanently ineligible list and has as passed away. This includes members of the 1919 ”Black Sox” team, like “Shoeless” Joe Jackson. It also applies to future cases.
What about Pete Rose?
While Pete Rose is still alive, the policy change will apply to him posthumously. He will be removed from the list of permanently inelgibles. He is not instantly eligible for the Hall of Fame because his ban was not lifted, just amended to end upon death.
When will the “Black Sox” players be considered for the Hall of Fame?
The Hall of Fame’s Past Overview Committee will create an eight-name ballot for candidates whose greatest impact on the game occurred before 1980. The Classic Baseball Era Committee will vote on this ballot in December 2027.
What is the meaning of this decision?
This decision could lead to the induction of several deserving players who were previously excluded due to their past transgressions. It’s a significant shift in how MLB views punishment and forgiveness.
Is ther any chance Pete Rose can be inducted into the Hall of Fame?
The Hall of Fame has to make a decision to change its rules. Even if Pete Rose is removed from the permanently ineligible list, he is still not eligible to be elected into the Hall of Fame as is per the current rules. He would have to be added to the ballot by the Hall of Fame to be eligible for consideration.
This new policy offers a chance for redemption and recognizes that the ultimate punishment should not extend beyond a lifetime. Stay tuned for updates on the Hall of Fame voting process!
