Crises are not defined by outcomes in friendly matches, yet England’s chaotic defensive performance, a cautious starting lineup, and the surrender of three goals within the first 30 minutes during a 4-3 defeat to Germany at Wembley will undoubtedly feel quite damaging.
The previous encounter between these two teams at this level resulted in far more positive outcomes for England, who triumphed in extra time over Germany thanks to Chloe Kelly’s iconic goal, clinching their first major trophy at the Euros in 2022.
With nine months to go before they begin their title defense in Switzerland, Sarina Wiegman faces a substantial task ahead if she intends to reinstate England’s stability and intimidation factor, especially following the lackluster display against Germany and a challenging European Championship qualifying campaign.
Germany came to London under new management from Christian Wück, along with several key absentees, including Lena Oberdorf due to injury, and Svenja Huth, Marina Hegering, and Lina Magull, all missing from the international break squad.
The unexpected aspect of England’s starting XI was the absence of surprises, as Wiegman opted for familiar faces over players currently in form at their clubs. Aggie Beever-Jones, Grace Clinton, Maya Le Tissier, Jess Park, and Alex Greenwood were all left out of the starting lineup. Jess Carter took the left-back position, while the Euro 2022-winning center-backs, Leah Williamson and Millie Bright, reunited despite their recent underwhelming performances for Arsenal and Chelsea. Meanwhile, Ella Toone donned the No 10 jersey in light of Lauren James’s injury. The only change in goal was Hannah Hampton taking the spot over the more established Mary Earps.
Wiegman’s choice to rely on players from the squad that secured a 2-1 victory against Germany in the last Euros final, with seven of those starters, seemed rather stagnant given the opportunity to experiment with fresh talent in friendly matches after a long time.
Wiegman had placed faith in the experience of players at Wembley, but that experience faltered almost immediately. A misplaced short pass from Williamson found Giovanna Hoffmann, who assisted Linda Dallmann; Bright then brought Dallmann down, resulting in a penalty. Giulia Gwinn, the German captain, converted it, sending a low shot into the corner, stunning the English team on their home ground.
England found the net next, with Alessia Russo capitalizing on Toone’s backheel, but Toone was flagged offside before the goal, dampening their celebrations. Better fortune didn’t follow right away, as Gwinn raced into open space on the right and struck the ball past Hampton.
Giulia Gwinn scores Germany’s second goal during the first half. Photograph: Zac Goodwin/PA
The first 11 minutes were humbling, and England’s situation worsened when Klara Bühl executed a powerful counterattack, scoring past Hampton at her near post. To claim England had been toothless would be misleading; Russo struck the post just before the third Germany goal, but they were struggling to keep pace.
Minutes after Bühl’s goal, fortune turned in England’s favor as a VAR review confirmed that Gwinn had touched the ball with her hand during a cross from Lauren Hemp, resulting in a penalty awarded to England. Georgia Stanway successfully converted from the spot and returned the ball to the center circle; while the players’ celebrations were subdued, the crowd expressed their joy.
England managed to narrow the gap again, exploiting the defensive weaknesses of the German side. Russo played a crucial role in the buildup, assisting Beth Mead, who squared the ball for Stanway to score.
Even after a lackluster performance leading to the third goal, Hampton redeemed herself with a brilliant save just before halftime, deflecting Dallmann’s 40-yard effort onto the crossbar.
skip past newsletter promotion
Sign up to Moving the Goalposts
No topic is too small or too big for us to cover as we deliver a twice-weekly roundup of the wonderful world of women’s football
Privacy Notice: Newsletters may contain info about charities, online ads, and content funded by outside parties. For more information see our Privacy Policy. We use Google reCaptcha to protect our website and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
after newsletter promotion
The second half saw a more composed yet still unpredictable pace. England’s defense was spared further embarrassment when Jule Brand scored, but the goal was disallowed due to Selina Cerci’s offside in the buildup.
Seeking to establish control, Wiegman reverted to the center-back pairing that reached the World Cup final in Australia, substituting the Arsenal defender for Greenwood as part of a pre-planned transition since Williamson was sidelined due to an anterior cruciate ligament injury.
Controversy arose surrounding Germany’s fourth goal, with Russo penalized for a foul on Pia-Sophie Wolter despite replays indicating that Russo had made contact with the ball first. Sara Däbritz converted the penalty, complicating England’s task even further.
However, there was time for one final England goal; after being denied moments earlier by an offside call, Hemp’s free-kick was mishandled by goalkeeper Ann-Katrin Berger, paving the way for Lucy Bronze to finish.
The gap had shrunk, but this marked the first instance under Wiegman that England had conceded four goals, and only the second time they had allowed more than two since her appointment in September 2021. The underlying issues were clear: unforced errors and an inability to handle the German press were at the core of a dismal defensive showing. In many ways, this performance and outcome arrived at a pivotal moment, granting players and staff time to reflect and make necessary adjustments.
England’s Defensive Woes Exposed in Stinging 4-3 Loss to Germany
The Match Overview
In a thrilling encounter that will be remembered for its intensity and drama, England faced off against Germany in a friendly match that ended in a shocking 4-3 defeat for the Three Lions. The game not only showcased the attacking prowess of both teams but also significantly exposed England’s defensive frailties that have become a growing concern leading into major tournaments.
Key Moments of the Match
- First Half Highlights: Germany opened the scoring early, capitalizing on England’s sluggish start.
- England’s Quick Response: The Three Lions equalized shortly after with a stunning goal from their star forward.
- Turning Point: A crucial defensive error allowed Germany to regain the lead just before halftime.
- Second Half Drama: Both teams exchanged goals, but England’s inability to maintain defensive discipline ultimately cost them dearly.
Analysis of England’s Defense
England’s loss to Germany raised significant questions about their defensive strategy. Here are some key areas that were notably deficient:
1. Inconsistent Communication
Defenders appeared to lack coherence, frequently leading to miscommunication during critical moments. This inconsistency allowed Germany to exploit gaps in the backline.
2. Poor Positioning
Several key goals resulted from defenders being caught out of position. England’s backline failed to maintain shape, allowing German forwards to exploit the spaces behind them.
3. Lack of Physicality
The match showcased a vulnerability in aerial duels, with England struggling to deal with Germany’s physical presence. This was particularly evident during set pieces, where England conceded two of their four goals.
4. Goalkeeping Errors
The England goalkeeper faced scrutiny after failing to command his area effectively. His inability to make key saves at crucial moments contributed to the loss.
Statistical Breakdown
| Statistic | England | Germany |
|---|---|---|
| Goals | 3 | 4 |
| Total Shots | 15 | 20 |
| Shots on Target | 7 | 10 |
| Possession (%) | 48% | 52% |
| Fouls Committed | 12 | 10 |
Benefits of Tactical Adjustments
Addressing these defensive issues is crucial for England as they prepare for upcoming competitions. Implementing the following tactical adjustments can help strengthen their backline:
- Enhanced Communication: Regular defensive drills to improve communication among the backline can mitigate errors.
- Positioning Clinics: Utilizing video analysis to teach defenders the importance of maintaining shape and discipline during matches.
- Physical Conditioning: Increasing strength training for defenders to enhance their ability to win aerial battles.
- Goalkeeper Coaching: Specialized training sessions for goalkeepers to improve command over their area.
Case Studies from the Match
Several moments from the match serve as case studies for England’s defensive shortcomings:
Case Study 1: Early Goals Conceded
Germany capitalized on an early mistake by England’s left-back, leading to a quick goal. This illustrates the importance of starting strong and maintaining focus.
Case Study 2: Set-Piece Vulnerability
Germany scored two goals from set pieces, highlighting the need for improved organization and physicality during these critical moments in matches.
Case Study 3: Late Game Collapse
In the final minutes, England conceded a preventable goal due to lack of tracking back. This emphasizes the need for players to maintain defensive responsibilities throughout the whole match.
First-Hand Experience: Player Insights
Following the match, several players voiced their frustrations and insights regarding the team’s defensive performance:
Player 1: Defender’s Reflection
“We need to take a hard look at our defensive tactics. It’s clear we need better cohesion and communication. These are things we can fix before the next big game.”
Player 2: Midfielder’s Perspective
“As a midfielder, I feel responsible to help defensively, but we need to work as a unit. It was disappointing to see us concede from situations that could have been avoided.”
What’s Next for England?
After the loss to Germany, England must regroup and focus on enhancing their defensive strategies. The coaching staff will need to analyze the match footage closely and implement changes to ensure that these defensive vulnerabilities are addressed before their next competitive outing.
Upcoming Fixtures
With important fixtures approaching, the team will benefit from rigorous training sessions focusing on defensive drills and cohesion-building exercises. Key upcoming matches include:
- England vs. Italy – Date: [Insert Date]
- England vs. Spain – Date: [Insert Date]
Final Thoughts
While the 4-3 loss to Germany was undoubtedly painful for England, it serves as an opportunity for growth and improvement. By addressing the defensive woes exposed in this match, the Three Lions can build a more resilient team capable of competing at the highest levels.
